Since 1997, the U.S. Department of Justice has carried out an antitrust investigation of Sotheby's and...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Since 1997, the U.S. Department of Justice has carried out an antitrust investigation of Sotheby's and Christie's on the suspicion that the two companies stifled competition by colluding on a host of business practices. It was revealed later that the two auction houses cooperated to set identical commission rates for buyers in 1992 and for sellers in 1995. They also agreed to exchange lists of preferred customers who were not charged a seller's fee or were charged lower fees because their collections were so eagerly sought by the auction houses. Furthermore, the two companies came up with ways of monitoring cach other for possible cheating, and held meetings at which they discussed the issue of cheating. On September 22, 2000, Sotheby's and Christie's agreed to pay $512 million in total and $256 million for each firm to settle claims that they cheated buyers and sellers dating back to 1992. Interestingly, the settlement came after negotiations in which each auction house tried to be the first to strike an agreement in the hope that the other would be forced to accept a worse deal. ("Auction houses disclose secret data." May 13, 2000, New York Times On-line Edition. "Art auction houses agree to pay $512 million in price-fixing case." September 23, 2000, New York Times On-line Edition. "Files of ex-Christie's chief fuel inquiry into art auction." October 8, 2000, New York Times On-line Edition.) Analyze how the two auction houses would compete for both buyers and sellers in the absence of secret agreements. а. Provision of antitrust law allows one of the participants in a scheme to receive amnesty in exchange for coming forward and disclosing everything it knows about the illegal activities. Explain how this provision affects the strategies of the two auction houses during the criminal investigation. Each auction house has the option of making up to $50 million of its payment in certificates to sellers, which would be transferable and could be used toward reducing commission costs on future transactions. Is it a good deal or bad deal for the auction houses compared with cash payments, and why? b. с. Since 1997, the U.S. Department of Justice has carried out an antitrust investigation of Sotheby's and Christie's on the suspicion that the two companies stifled competition by colluding on a host of business practices. It was revealed later that the two auction houses cooperated to set identical commission rates for buyers in 1992 and for sellers in 1995. They also agreed to exchange lists of preferred customers who were not charged a seller's fee or were charged lower fees because their collections were so eagerly sought by the auction houses. Furthermore, the two companies came up with ways of monitoring cach other for possible cheating, and held meetings at which they discussed the issue of cheating. On September 22, 2000, Sotheby's and Christie's agreed to pay $512 million in total and $256 million for each firm to settle claims that they cheated buyers and sellers dating back to 1992. Interestingly, the settlement came after negotiations in which each auction house tried to be the first to strike an agreement in the hope that the other would be forced to accept a worse deal. ("Auction houses disclose secret data." May 13, 2000, New York Times On-line Edition. "Art auction houses agree to pay $512 million in price-fixing case." September 23, 2000, New York Times On-line Edition. "Files of ex-Christie's chief fuel inquiry into art auction." October 8, 2000, New York Times On-line Edition.) Analyze how the two auction houses would compete for both buyers and sellers in the absence of secret agreements. а. Provision of antitrust law allows one of the participants in a scheme to receive amnesty in exchange for coming forward and disclosing everything it knows about the illegal activities. Explain how this provision affects the strategies of the two auction houses during the criminal investigation. Each auction house has the option of making up to $50 million of its payment in certificates to sellers, which would be transferable and could be used toward reducing commission costs on future transactions. Is it a good deal or bad deal for the auction houses compared with cash payments, and why? b. с.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer Description 1 i In the absence of secret agreements two auction houses would not know the com... View the full answer
Related Book For
Probability and Statistics for Engineering and the Sciences
ISBN: 978-1305251809
9th edition
Authors: Jay L. Devore
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
The manager of a photography studio has carried out an experiment to compare the attractiveness of four different poster-size photographs for use in the display window. During 23 business days of the...
-
A chemical engineer has carried out an experiment to study the effects of the fixed factors of vat pressure (A), cooking time of pulp (B), and hardwood concentration (C) on he strength of paper. The...
-
Companies U and L are identical in every respect except that U is unlevered while L has $10 million of 5% bonds outstanding. Assume that (1) all of the MM assumptions are met, (2) both firms are...
-
>> ((5.2^3-6.4^2+3) / (1.6^8-2))+((13.3)^1.5/(5))ans 12.2075MATLABIS THE ANSWER CORRECT? \( \gg\left(\left(5.2^{\wedge} 3-6.4^{\wedge} 2+3ight) /\left(1.6^{\wedge} 8-2ight)ight)+\left((13.3)^{\wedge}...
-
Albert has a weekly allowance of $17, all of which he spends on used CDs (C) and movie rentals (M), whose respective prices are $4 and $3. His utility from these purchases is given by U(C) + V(M). If...
-
What is meant by check tampering?
-
It has been argued that to be classified as a professional one must offer services to the public rather than simply be an employee of an organization. As such, most employees of an organization,...
-
Develop a vendor-rating form that represents your comparison of the education offered by universities in which you considered (or are considering) enrolling. Fill in the necessary data, and identify...
-
How Walmart uses EDLP as an advantage with the help of its supply chain ?
-
The NCAA is making plans for distributing tickets to the upcoming regional basketball championships. Up to 10,000 available seats will be divided between the media, the competing universities, and...
-
Do males differ from females in the amount of reduction for each of your assigned measure (weight)? The test that should be used is regression analysis. Please provide the entire output from Excel...
-
Classify each of the following variables as categorical or quantitative. a. The number of social media accounts you have (Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram, etc.) b. Preferred soccer team c....
-
Which of your personal attributes will most help you succeed as an entrepreneur?
-
Of all cancer cases around the world in 2012, 13% had lung cancer, 11.9% had breast cancer, 9.7% had colorectal cancer, 7.9% had prostate cancer, 6.8% had stomach cancer, and 50.7% had other types of...
-
What sources of capital do you have? Are you willing to take on a home equity loan? Use your personal credit cards? How much of a nest egg do you need to feel comfortable pursuing a new venture?
-
What fiduciary duty do you have with your current employer? Does your proposed new venture rely on proprietary information belonging to your previous employer? Are you materially interfering with...
-
9. What is a benefit of a multilayer switch (MLS) over a Layer 2 switch? A. Less bandwidth B. Routing functions C. Fewer features D. Fewer ports 10. Which device should be used if you need to send...
-
Vectors are drawn from the center of a regular n-sided polygon in the plane to the vertices of the polygon. Show that the sum of the vectors is zero.
-
An experimenter wishes to obtain a CI for the difference between true average breaking strength for cables manufactured by company I and by company II. Suppose breaking strength is normally...
-
A study was carried out to compare two different methods, injection and nasal spray, for administering flu vaccine to children under the age of 5. All 8000 children in the study were given both an...
-
When the population distribution is normal and n is large, the sample standard deviation S has approximately a normal distribution with E(S) and V(S) 2/(2n). We already know that in this case, for...
-
The noncontrolling interest account arises on the consolidated balance sheet and is reported as a component of shareholders equity. Many financial analysts, however, regard the account as a component...
-
The equity method is often described as a one-line consolidation. Discuss the similarities of the equity method and consolidated reporting. Discuss how these methods differ in their financial...
-
Accumulated other comprehensive income (AOCI) appears as a subsection of shareholders equity on the balance sheet. Discuss the components of AOCI. What information does the AOCI convey to financial...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App