Use incremental challenger-defender analysis to determine the best of the 3 mutually exclusive alternatives. Assume MARR...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Use incremental challenger-defender analysis to determine the best of the 3 mutually exclusive alternatives. Assume MARR of 7% and a 5 year life. Initial Investment O&M Costs Annual Benefit Salvage Value Alt A $5,000 $200 $1,200 $1,300 First order lowest initial investment to highest initial investment: Alt B Initial Investment $3,000 O&M Costs Annual Benefit Salvage Value $400 $1,000 $700 Alt B $3,000 $400 $1,000 Alt C $4,000 $400 $1,200 $700 $1,200 Alt C $4,000 $400 Alt A $5,000 $200 $1,200 $1,200 $1,200 $1,300 Check to see if IRR of A is> MARR NPVA = -10,000+ 2200*(P/A, i, 6) + 3000*(P/F, i, 6) Using MARR of 10% for i. NPVA = -10,000+ 2,200*()+3,000(.....) = 1,274 Since NPV is positive, IRR > MARR. A is the............ |NPVC-A = -2,000 + 300(P/A, i, 6) + 2000(P/F, i, 6) Using MARR of 10% for i. NPVC-A-2000 + 300(...) + 2000(.....) =.………..... Since NPV is positive, IRR > MARR. C is the new Use incremental challenger-defender analysis to determine the best of the 3 mutually exclusive alternatives. Assume MARR of 7% and a 5 year life. Initial Investment O&M Costs Annual Benefit Salvage Value Alt A $5,000 $200 $1,200 $1,300 First order lowest initial investment to highest initial investment: Alt B Initial Investment $3,000 O&M Costs Annual Benefit Salvage Value $400 $1,000 $700 Alt B $3,000 $400 $1,000 Alt C $4,000 $400 $1,200 $700 $1,200 Alt C $4,000 $400 Alt A $5,000 $200 $1,200 $1,200 $1,200 $1,300 Check to see if IRR of A is> MARR NPVA = -10,000+ 2200*(P/A, i, 6) + 3000*(P/F, i, 6) Using MARR of 10% for i. NPVA = -10,000+ 2,200*()+3,000(.....) = 1,274 Since NPV is positive, IRR > MARR. A is the............ |NPVC-A = -2,000 + 300(P/A, i, 6) + 2000(P/F, i, 6) Using MARR of 10% for i. NPVC-A-2000 + 300(...) + 2000(.....) =.………..... Since NPV is positive, IRR > MARR. C is the new
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Here are the stepbystep calculations 1 Check IRR of Alternative A Cash Flows for A Initial Investmen... View the full answer
Related Book For
Engineering Economic Analysis
ISBN: 9780195168075
9th Edition
Authors: Donald Newnan, Ted Eschanbach, Jerome Lavelle
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
The following additional information is available for the Dr. Ivan and Irene Incisor family from Chapters 1-5. Ivan's grandfather died and left a portfolio of municipal bonds. In 2012, they pay Ivan...
-
The manager in a canned food processing plant is trying to decide between two labeling machines. Their respective costs and benefits are as follows: Assume an interest rate of 12%. Use annual cash...
-
Bluelamp plc has grown from a company with 10,000 turnover to one with a 17m turnover and 1.8m profit in the last five years. The existing owners have put all their financial resources into the firm...
-
Acceleration is the rate of change of velocity with time. Is the acceleration vector always aligned with the velocity vector? Explain.
-
A geothermal supply of hot water at 80 lbf/in 2, 300 F is fed to an insulated flash evaporator at the rate of 10,000 lbm/h, A stream of saturated liquid at 30 lbf/in 2 is drained from the bottom of...
-
Washington Distributors, whose accounting year ends on December 31, had the following normal balances in its ledger accounts at December 31: During the year, the accounting department prepared...
-
The following data are taken from Stockton Wholesale Company's May payroll: Assume that the company is subject to a two percent state unemployment tax (due to a favorable experience rating) and a 0.6...
-
During audits of internal control over financial reporting of various issuers, the auditors encountered the independent situations below. For each situation a through e select from the following list...
-
(Related to Checkpoint 12.1) (Calculating project cash flows and NPV) You are considering expanding your product line that currently consists of skateboards to include gas-powered skateboards, and...
-
A division of your company purchased a large quantity of new desktop computers during the current fiscal year. An internal audit manager has asked you to audit the process used to acquire the...
-
The Bombay Beverage Company has heavily advertised its social responsibility to the environment and community. In its advertisements, the company touts how its recycling efforts have reduced its...
-
The housing bubble could be described as an inflated price for houses in which a houses price is not supported by the rents it could earn. True/False
-
Which of the following correctly describes the SECs finding against Edison? (a) Edisons revenue recognition practices did not contravene GAAP, but failed to present an accurate picture of the issuers...
-
____________ debt was taken off Adelphias books, and new debt was taken ____________ without being reported on the balance sheet.
-
Edison Schools is presented in the chapter as an example of: (a) Failure to disclose related-party transactions. (b) Inadequate disclosures in its Management Discussion and Analysis (MD&A). (c)...
-
Collateralized debt obligations consist of home loans pooled with other loans, such as car loans, credit card debt, and student loans, which are carved into tranches and securitized by the investment...
-
A start-up firm that is entering an industry usually has to convince potential buyers that its goods are reliable and provide sufficient value in relation to the price that the firm intends to...
-
3M Company reports the following financial statement amounts in its 10-K report: a. Compute the receivables, inventory, and PPE turnover ratios for both 2018 and 2017. (Receivables turnover and...
-
For J&W Graphics Supply, compute the current ratio. Is this a financially healthy company? Explain. J & W Graphics Supply Balance Sheet Data (thousands) Assets Cash...
-
A 20-year-old student decided to set aside $100 on his 2pt birthday for investment. Each subsequent year through his 55th birthday, he plans to increase the sum for investment on a $100 arithmetic...
-
An engineer has a fluctuating future budget for the maintenance of a particular machine. During each 01 the first 5 years, $1000 per year will be budgeted. During the second 5 years, the annual...
-
The Wall Street Journal quoted a market price of 102 for an issue of 8 percent bonds of a major U.S. corporation. What would be the market price for \(\$ 25,000\) face value of these bonds (ignoring...
-
Ace Garage has an unpaid mortgage loan of \(\$ 63,210\), payable at \(\$ 1,200\) per month. An amortization table indicates that \(\$ 527\) of the current monthly payment represents interest expense....
-
A \(\$ 200\) million bond issue of NDP Corp. (a liquid company) recently matured. The entire maturity value was paid from a bond sinking fund. What effect did this transaction have on the company's...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App