EMPLOYMENT LAW AND LEGISLATION Case Briefing Worksheet A case brief is a summary of a judicial...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
EMPLOYMENT LAW AND LEGISLATION Case Briefing Worksheet A case brief is a summary of a judicial opinion outlined in a form that clarifies the facts, issues, holding and rationale in that opinion. It is used by attorneys and legal researchers to provide a quick review of the key elements of an opinion. Case briefs have several purposes. Good briefs will help you to better understand the case, and provide good case summaries for future reference. If you are learning to brief a case for the first time, remember there are several ways to brief a case. With practice, you will find a format that works best for you. For our purposes, however, every case brief should include the elements identified below: 1. Case name and citation The names of the principal litigants, volume, reporter and page of the decision should appear at the top of the case brief. Include the court and year of decision in parenthesis. Doe v. State of California (2002) 23 Cal.App.4th 558. 2. Example: Facts In a paragraph or two, state the essential facts that led to the controversy. Be concise, and include relevant information so that the nature of the controversy is understood. Include in your brief only those facts that are legally relevant. A fact is legally relevant if it had an impact on the case's outcome. For example, in a personal injury action arising from a car accident, the color of the parties' cars seldom would be relevant to the case's outcome. Similarly, if the plaintiff and defendant presented different versions of the facts, you should describe those differences only if they are relevant to the court's consideration of the case. Because you will not know which facts are legally relevant until you have read and deciphered the entire case, do not try to brief a case while reading it for the first time. For our purposes, exclude elements of procedure in the lower court, unless they are critical to the resolution of the case. 3. issue(s) State the issue or issues identified by the opinion in question form. Be sure to specify the provisions of law being interpreted. The issue is typically a single narrow question or series of narrow questions that the court is asked to adjudicate. The issues are often explicitly stated by the court in their judgment. Example: Did the Department violate Doe's right to representation when it denied his request for union representation at an investigatory interview? 4. Holding The holding is the court's answer to the question posed in the case. A weak statement of the holding to the example in Section 3 would be "yes." A better statement of the holding answers each issue in a concise and brief statement by identifying the court's resolution of the controversy. Example: The Department violated Doe's right to representation by denying his request for union representation at an investigatory interview when Doe reasonably believed the meeting would result in disciplinary action. 5. Rule(s) The rule is the law that the court applied in the case to achieve the holding. The rule is usually a preexisting statement of the law that most often comes from a constitutional provision, statute, and/or case precedent. 6. Example: Rationale To establish a prima facie violation of the right to representation under the Dills Act, the charging party must establish the following elements: 1) the charging party requested union representation; 2) the representation requested was for an investigatory interview; and 3) the employee reasonably believed the meeting would result in disciplinary action. This section describes how the tribunal resolved the issue. This section of the case brief may be the most important, because you must understand the court's reasoning to analyze it and to apply it to other fact situations, such as those on the exam. Starting with the first issue, summarize all the logical steps the court took in reaching its holding. Keep in mind that the court's rationale can come from several different sources, including case precedent, something particular in the facts, and/or public policy. For the purposes of this exercise, to you a dissenting or concanting opinion, if any. 7. Disposition This section describes how the case was resolved. Did the court decide in favor of the plaintiff or the defendant? What remedy, if any, did the court grant? 8. Your Opinion Do you agree with the court? Briefly (i.e. one or two sentences) explain your opinion. EMPLOYMENT LAW AND LEGISLATION Case Briefing Worksheet A case brief is a summary of a judicial opinion outlined in a form that clarifies the facts, issues, holding and rationale in that opinion. It is used by attorneys and legal researchers to provide a quick review of the key elements of an opinion. Case briefs have several purposes. Good briefs will help you to better understand the case, and provide good case summaries for future reference. If you are learning to brief a case for the first time, remember there are several ways to brief a case. With practice, you will find a format that works best for you. For our purposes, however, every case brief should include the elements identified below: 1. Case name and citation The names of the principal litigants, volume, reporter and page of the decision should appear at the top of the case brief. Include the court and year of decision in parenthesis. Doe v. State of California (2002) 23 Cal.App.4th 558. 2. Example: Facts In a paragraph or two, state the essential facts that led to the controversy. Be concise, and include relevant information so that the nature of the controversy is understood. Include in your brief only those facts that are legally relevant. A fact is legally relevant if it had an impact on the case's outcome. For example, in a personal injury action arising from a car accident, the color of the parties' cars seldom would be relevant to the case's outcome. Similarly, if the plaintiff and defendant presented different versions of the facts, you should describe those differences only if they are relevant to the court's consideration of the case. Because you will not know which facts are legally relevant until you have read and deciphered the entire case, do not try to brief a case while reading it for the first time. For our purposes, exclude elements of procedure in the lower court, unless they are critical to the resolution of the case. 3. issue(s) State the issue or issues identified by the opinion in question form. Be sure to specify the provisions of law being interpreted. The issue is typically a single narrow question or series of narrow questions that the court is asked to adjudicate. The issues are often explicitly stated by the court in their judgment. Example: Did the Department violate Doe's right to representation when it denied his request for union representation at an investigatory interview? 4. Holding The holding is the court's answer to the question posed in the case. A weak statement of the holding to the example in Section 3 would be "yes." A better statement of the holding answers each issue in a concise and brief statement by identifying the court's resolution of the controversy. Example: The Department violated Doe's right to representation by denying his request for union representation at an investigatory interview when Doe reasonably believed the meeting would result in disciplinary action. 5. Rule(s) The rule is the law that the court applied in the case to achieve the holding. The rule is usually a preexisting statement of the law that most often comes from a constitutional provision, statute, and/or case precedent. 6. Example: Rationale To establish a prima facie violation of the right to representation under the Dills Act, the charging party must establish the following elements: 1) the charging party requested union representation; 2) the representation requested was for an investigatory interview; and 3) the employee reasonably believed the meeting would result in disciplinary action. This section describes how the tribunal resolved the issue. This section of the case brief may be the most important, because you must understand the court's reasoning to analyze it and to apply it to other fact situations, such as those on the exam. Starting with the first issue, summarize all the logical steps the court took in reaching its holding. Keep in mind that the court's rationale can come from several different sources, including case precedent, something particular in the facts, and/or public policy. For the purposes of this exercise, to you a dissenting or concanting opinion, if any. 7. Disposition This section describes how the case was resolved. Did the court decide in favor of the plaintiff or the defendant? What remedy, if any, did the court grant? 8. Your Opinion Do you agree with the court? Briefly (i.e. one or two sentences) explain your opinion.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Case Name and Citation Smith v XYZ Corporation 2023 45 F3d 789 2 Facts Smith an employee of XYZ Corporation was terminated after being absent from w... View the full answer
Related Book For
Income Tax Fundamentals 2013
ISBN: 9781285586618
31st Edition
Authors: Gerald E. Whittenburg, Martha Altus Buller, Steven L Gill
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
What is the definition of negotiation? a . The process of communicating effectively with others to achieve your goals. b . The process of manipulating others to get what you want. c . The process of...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Googles ease of use and superior search results have propelled the search engine to its num- ber one status, ousting the early dominance of competitors such as WebCrawler and Infos- eek. Even later...
-
Match the items below by entering the appropriate code letter in the space provided. An entry that involves three or more accounts Transferring journal entries to ledger accounts The side which...
-
x + y + z = 5 x + y - 4z = 10 - 4x + y + z = 0 Solve the system by inverting the coefficient matrix and using Theorem 1.6.2.
-
Consider the following data on traffic accidents: Calculate. (a) The probability that a randomly chosen driver will have an accident this year, (b) The probability that a driver is between 46 and 65...
-
10. ROLE REVERSAL The Role Reversal feature challenges you to create your own exam question. The goal is to think creatively and accurately. Crafting questions is a good way to reinforce what you...
-
The Skyline Motel opened for business on May 1, 2014. Its trial balance before adjustment on May 31 is as follows. In addition to those accounts listed on the trial balance, the chart of accounts for...
-
The statement of financial position of A, B, C partnership as of December 31, 2020 is presented below: CASH P20,000 LIABILITIES 50,000 OTHER ASSETS 280,000 A, LOAN 25,000 A, CAPITAL 125,000 B,...
-
To demonstrate flavor aversion learning (that is, learning to dislike a flavor that is associated with becoming sick), researchers gave one group of laboratory rats an injection of lithium chloride...
-
The Carib Feed Company manufactures a mix for pigs in a single process. The following information is available: Input Material Material Added Direct Labour Cost Incurred Manufacturing Overhead...
-
Valuation of investment in Bonds by SVB KPMG is being questioned about their audit report of Silcon Valley bank (SVB) issued 14 days before the lender collapsed. The focus of their audit reporting is...
-
The following extracts from the profit and loss account and balance sheet have been provided: Extract from profit and loss account Taxation Year to 31 December 20X1 Year to 31 December 20X0 108,000...
-
1. Why is it more affordable to retain customers than looking for new ones? 2. How woulda marketer handle or retain a customer that is price sensitive or the bargain hunter? 3. How woulda...
-
a) The 150-kg uniform crate rests on the 10-kg cart (see Figure 1). Determine the maximum force P that can be applied to the handle without causing the crate to slip or tip on the cart. The...
-
Consider the following problem where the in put is an an array A [1...n]. Each entry could either be a number or a special symbol NULL. We want to output an array that is A but with all special...
-
Which provision could best be justified as encouraging small business? a. Ordinary loss allowed on $ 1244 stuck. b. Percentage depletion. c. Domestic production activates deductions. d. Interest...
-
Indicate whether each of the items listed below would be included (I) in or excluded (E) from gross income for the 2012 tax year. ________a. Welfare payments ________b. Commissions ________c. Hobby...
-
Kent Pham, CPA, is a 45-year-old single taxpayer living at 169 Trendie Street, La Jolla, CA 92037. His Social Security number is 865-68-9635. In 2012, Kent's W-2 as the controller of a local...
-
The following additional information is available for the Dr. Ivan and Irene Incisor family. Ivan and Irene have the following investment income, in addition to that reported in Chapter 1: Dividends...
-
The following transactions relate to topics in this chapter. a. Purchased inventory on account, terms \(2 / n, n / 30\), accounted for using the perpetual method. b. Collected sales taxes on a...
-
Atlas Inc. issues short-term interest-bearing notes and uses the proceeds to purchase inventory. The company's profits for the year remain unchanged. Required Indicate how the use of the notes would...
-
List and briefly explain the primary characteristics of long-term debt securities. What are the primary distinctions between a debt security and an equity security?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App