Question:
Many people ask, "Are executives worth their very high pay?" As noted in the chapter, this is a difficult question to answer because the benefits an effective executive brings to the company are hard to measure. One thing we can do, however, is to see if changes in executive pay are correlated with changes in company performance. If pay increases when company performance increases, and vice versa, then this would be an indication that pay practices are aligned with the interests of shareholders. To study this question, we have data (from The New York Times, April 10, 2011) for the 30 highest paid chief executive officers (CEOs) in the U.S. The data is shown below, which includes 29 of these 30 CEOs (because he was a new CEO in 2010, the change in compensation could not be determined for the fourth-ranked CEO, Michael D. White of DirecTV, and he is not included in the list below):
In the above table, the change in compensation is measured as the percentage change in total compensation from 2009 to 2010; total return (our measure of company performance) is measured by the percentage change in stock price plus dividends.
Required:
Using regression and/or correlation analysis examine the above data and determine whether there is a significant relationship between the change in compensation for these executives and the change in the company's performance. That is, does it appear from your analysis, that the CEOs pay is aligned with shareholder interests? Comment briefly on your findings.
Transcribed Image Text:
% Change from 2009 to 201 Total Total Compensation Return Phillipe Dauman Ray Irani Lawrence Ellison John Lundgren Brian Roberts RobertIgr Alan Mulally Samuel Palmisano David Farr Howard Schultz William Welden Louis Camalleri Randall Stephenson Miles White 140 142 17 253 13 30 48 19 233 45 acom Occidental Petroleum Black & Decker Comcast Disney Ford Motor Emerson Electric Starbuck:s Johnson& Johns on Phillip Morris AT&T AbbotLabs 16 41 3M United Technolosias Bamk of New York Coca-Cola Lockheed Martin Cisco Systems Anadarko Petroleum ConocoPhillips Verizon Dow Chemical Qualcomm Wells Fargo George Buckley Louis Chenevert Robert Kelly Muhtar Kent Robert Stevens 16 18 106 John Chambers James Hackett James Mulva Ivan Seidenberg Andrew Liveris Paul Jacobs John Stumpf Susan Ivey RupertMurdoch James M. Cracchiolo 19 13 16 News Corp American Financial