An Internet user who types “naked female body” into the Google Image search engine will see thumbnail images of photo files posted on other Web sites, including the pornographic

“Perfect 10” Web site. While these small images reside on Google’s servers, clicking on them directs the user to the full-size image, and a frame of the original Web site appears on the Google screen.

a. What argument does Perfect 10 have against Google? How might Google defend itself?

b. Internet Assignment Find out how the Ninth Circuit ruled in the actual case.