You are a new police officer and you are talking with other officers before roll call. The group is loud and energetically proposing various gruesome torture techniques to get Al Queda operative to talk. There is some amount of hyperbole in the discussion, but also the sincere belief that torture is justified by some circumstances.

How do you feel about this position? If you object to torture, would you make your position known? Please post your answers here. Defend your positions.