Question
1/ Helen owned a 40-room hotel adjacent to a busy highway. In 2016, Dayla purchased the hotel from Helen for $1,000,000. During the course of
1/ Helen owned a 40-room hotel adjacent to a busy highway. In 2016, Dayla purchased the hotel from Helen
for $1,000,000. During the course of negotiations, Helen told Dayla that the motel earned $120,000 in
2015. During the 1st year of operations under Dayla, the hotel only earned $90,000. Dayla learned that the
hotel had only earned $119,000 in 2015 and that Helen failed to tell her that a bypass to the highway is
being planned that will redirect most of the traffic away from the front of the hotel. Dayla sued Helen for
misrepresentation.
a. What would Dayla need to prove to be successful in suing Helen for misrepresentation?
b. Is Dayla likely to be successful? Explain.
c. What remedies are available for a successful misrepresentation action?
2/ GPD Property Developers Ltd is in the business of developing real estate. It was interested in a
condominium development project but required a loan of $500,000. The bank required financial
statements as part of the loan granting process. GPD engaged the services of Aviva, an accountant to
prepare statements. GPD told Aviva the specific purpose for which the statements were being prepared
and agreed to pay $10,000 for her services. The contract between GPD and Aviva stated that Aviva's
liability for losses due to errors in the financial statements was limited to $10,000. Aviva prepared the
financial statements and the bank relied on them in making the decision to lend $500,000 to GPD. Golda, a
shareholder of GPD also used the financial statements to make a further investment of $100,000 in GPD.
Subsequently, GPD defaulted on the loan and the bank had to write it off. Also, the value of Golda's
investment fell from $100,000 to $1000. An investigation revealed that there was a serious error in the
financial statements, which Aviva should have detected. The bank and Golda sued Aviva for damages on
the basis of negligent misrepresentation.
a. What must the bank and Golda prove to be successful? (ie, set out the applicable law)
b. Are they likely to be successful? Explain.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started