1. MOBILE ONE Limited, a telecommunications service provider listed on the Singapore Exchange, has just announced its latest quarterly financial results. Despite the substantial deteriorating net profit after tax figure, the price quoted has remained unchanged at $$3.00. Subsequent to the announcement, the analysts fraternity (i.e. the analyst community) has provided prospective price guidance (i.e. future price guidance) on the said company's stock, with some recommending an 'UNDERPERFORM' (i.e. likely to be underperforming the market performance), some NEURTAL/MARKET PERFORM' (i.e. performance likely to be in line with the market performance), while some have recommended 'OVERPERFORM' (i.e. likely to be performing better than the market). You are the Head of Corporate Treasury of a local (Malaysia) public listed holding company with very substantial cash and cash equivalent surplus to (i.e. more than) the investment needs of the holding company. Your Chairman is interested in utilizing these free cash flows to invest in MOBILE ONE, but he is very perplexed (i.e. confused) over the differing valuations provided by the analysts fraternity. Required: As the Corporate Treasury Head, the Chairman has approached you for some advice on the reasons for the different prospective valuations for MOBILE ONE. Your answer should include an explanation of the various methods used for valuing firms. [Total: 20 marks] 1. MOBILE ONE Limited, a telecommunications service provider listed on the Singapore Exchange, has just announced its latest quarterly financial results. Despite the substantial deteriorating net profit after tax figure, the price quoted has remained unchanged at $$3.00. Subsequent to the announcement, the analysts fraternity (i.e. the analyst community) has provided prospective price guidance (i.e. future price guidance) on the said company's stock, with some recommending an 'UNDERPERFORM' (i.e. likely to be underperforming the market performance), some NEURTAL/MARKET PERFORM' (i.e. performance likely to be in line with the market performance), while some have recommended 'OVERPERFORM' (i.e. likely to be performing better than the market). You are the Head of Corporate Treasury of a local (Malaysia) public listed holding company with very substantial cash and cash equivalent surplus to (i.e. more than) the investment needs of the holding company. Your Chairman is interested in utilizing these free cash flows to invest in MOBILE ONE, but he is very perplexed (i.e. confused) over the differing valuations provided by the analysts fraternity. Required: As the Corporate Treasury Head, the Chairman has approached you for some advice on the reasons for the different prospective valuations for MOBILE ONE. Your answer should include an explanation of the various methods used for valuing firms. [Total: 20 marks]
