1. Provides an analysis of the strength of the negligence claims against each defendant. One of the potential defendants is Maria Duarte and in relation to her, please only consider at this stage the question of whether she might owe Mr Arshad a duty of care - depending on the view we take on that, we would investigate whether she would have the funds to pay Mr Arshad any damages before looking any further into the legal merits of a claim against her. In relation to any other defendants, please consider all relevant aspects of any negligence claims. Please can you begin your email with 3 or 4 sentences summarising your analyses. Please do not consider any vicarious claims against the hospital at this stage