5. Gerald, due to his old age, has become very weak. Nathalie, knowing this, threatens Gerald that she would punch him in the face, like she has done so in the past, if Gerald would not give all his estate to her. Gerald, in his final moments, managed to make a wholly hand-written will, signed, which was signed and dated, stating that "he is giving away all his property to charity".

Question:

A. Is there a valid will? Why or why not?

B. In relation to Letter A, Nathalie claims that the will is not valid, since there was no witness that Gerald created the will. Is her contention valid? Why or why not?