- (5 points) In addition to the financial analyses, Engineer Charlies table is missing some basic arithmetical information. Can you complete the information for him outlined in red boxes?
Yes
- (5 points) What is the most appropriate analysis period to compare the alternatives?
40 years
- (10 points) What is the EUAW for each of the alternatives?
- (5 points) What is the Payback Period/ Breakeven Point for each of the alternatives?
Alt-A = 1.21 years
Alt B = 1.37 years
Alt C= 4.54 years
- (10 points) What is the NPW of each of the alternatives?
- (5 points) What is the IRR for each of the alternatives?
- (10 points) What is the IRR for Alt.3 2 and for Alt.2 1?
Item Do-Nothing g a a d d Total-CAPEX Equipmenta Ancillary Components Labora Engineering Feeso Risk Contingencya Total-Net-Annual Savings Total Annual-OPEX(COST) Fuela Replacement Parts Consumable Supplies Chemicals and Antiscalents Service Feesa Labor - Junior Technicanso Labor-Sr.-Techs/-Foremand Labor-Engineerd Annual-Budget-for-Energy Estimated-Salvage Value Useful Life-in-Years NPVA IRRO Payback.Period/-Breakeven-Point GHG-Emissions (tons-CO2-per-year) Water-Footprint-(gallons-per-year) Full-Power-Noise-Level-(dB)-at-20-ft. Technology Stability-Riska Health-&-Safety-Risk-to-Operators Technology Obsolescence Risko $0-6 $0-20 $0-0 $0-0 $0-0 $0-0 $0-6 $3,434,200.0 $2,300,000.00 $78,000-0 $42,500.00 32,000 $56,700-0 $350,000.00 $250,000-0 $325,000.00 $3,434,200-0 N/A Should've Died Years Agon N/A N/AD N/A 2430 168,000,000 900 VERY-LOW. MED-to-HIGH- LOWO Alt-1:--In-kind Alt.:2:-Replace-with-High- Alt.-3:-Replace-Entire Replacement-with-Newer. Efficiency-Brayton-Cycle Power-Infrastructure-with- Models Co-regeneration Systems Hydrogen-Fuel Cell-Planta $4,150,000-2 $4,698,438-6 $15,596,875-6 $1,300,000.00 1,575,000 $5,750,000.00 a $525,000-0 $393,750-0 $1.437.500.00 $1,105,000-0 $1,260,000.00 $2.875.000.0 $390,000-0 $530,000-0 $2,415,000.00 $830,000-0 $939,6886 $3,119,375.0 $952,905-6 $1,202,894-0 2,818,450 2,481,2950 $2,231,307-01 $615,750-6 $1,380,000-6 $1,352,400-6 $0-0 $65,520-01 $45,864-0 $25,000-0 $35,700-0 $24.990.00 $15,000-0 $26,880-0 $18,816-0 $0-0 $48, 1950 $33,7370 $75,750-0 a $350,000.00 $255,500-6 $100,000-200 $250.000-8 $175,000-0 $175,000-0 $325,000-0 $325,000-0 $225,000-0 $3,434,200-6 $3,434,200-6 $3,434,200-2 $415,000-6 $328,891-6 $779,844-0 10-take-it-4-times) 20(take-it-2-times) 400 ? 20 ? ? ? ? 1.21 years 1.37 years 4.54-yearse 2200 1500 00 142,000,000 110,000,0000 47,000,0000 750 700 250 VERY-LOW LOWO HIGH MEDC MED-to-HIGH LOWO LOWA LOWA UNKNOWN a g a Item Do-Nothing g a a d d Total-CAPEX Equipmenta Ancillary Components Labora Engineering Feeso Risk Contingencya Total-Net-Annual Savings Total Annual-OPEX(COST) Fuela Replacement Parts Consumable Supplies Chemicals and Antiscalents Service Feesa Labor - Junior Technicanso Labor-Sr.-Techs/-Foremand Labor-Engineerd Annual-Budget-for-Energy Estimated-Salvage Value Useful Life-in-Years NPVA IRRO Payback.Period/-Breakeven-Point GHG-Emissions (tons-CO2-per-year) Water-Footprint-(gallons-per-year) Full-Power-Noise-Level-(dB)-at-20-ft. Technology Stability-Riska Health-&-Safety-Risk-to-Operators Technology Obsolescence Risko $0-6 $0-20 $0-0 $0-0 $0-0 $0-0 $0-6 $3,434,200.0 $2,300,000.00 $78,000-0 $42,500.00 32,000 $56,700-0 $350,000.00 $250,000-0 $325,000.00 $3,434,200-0 N/A Should've Died Years Agon N/A N/AD N/A 2430 168,000,000 900 VERY-LOW. MED-to-HIGH- LOWO Alt-1:--In-kind Alt.:2:-Replace-with-High- Alt.-3:-Replace-Entire Replacement-with-Newer. Efficiency-Brayton-Cycle Power-Infrastructure-with- Models Co-regeneration Systems Hydrogen-Fuel Cell-Planta $4,150,000-2 $4,698,438-6 $15,596,875-6 $1,300,000.00 1,575,000 $5,750,000.00 a $525,000-0 $393,750-0 $1.437.500.00 $1,105,000-0 $1,260,000.00 $2.875.000.0 $390,000-0 $530,000-0 $2,415,000.00 $830,000-0 $939,6886 $3,119,375.0 $952,905-6 $1,202,894-0 2,818,450 2,481,2950 $2,231,307-01 $615,750-6 $1,380,000-6 $1,352,400-6 $0-0 $65,520-01 $45,864-0 $25,000-0 $35,700-0 $24.990.00 $15,000-0 $26,880-0 $18,816-0 $0-0 $48, 1950 $33,7370 $75,750-0 a $350,000.00 $255,500-6 $100,000-200 $250.000-8 $175,000-0 $175,000-0 $325,000-0 $325,000-0 $225,000-0 $3,434,200-6 $3,434,200-6 $3,434,200-2 $415,000-6 $328,891-6 $779,844-0 10-take-it-4-times) 20(take-it-2-times) 400 ? 20 ? ? ? ? 1.21 years 1.37 years 4.54-yearse 2200 1500 00 142,000,000 110,000,0000 47,000,0000 750 700 250 VERY-LOW LOWO HIGH MEDC MED-to-HIGH LOWO LOWA LOWA UNKNOWN a g a
