Agree or disagree with this thought, why?

While reading the depos, I felt like he was trying to dodge every question possible. Almost all of his response was "I don't recall". which was a huge red ag. I think it would have been fair if he wasn't able to recall some information but in this case he basically didn't have much answers at all. As Mr. Nelson stated in his declaration that he basically didn't have much recollection about the operational procedures. activities etc. at all for someone who has been managing the IT department. The emails in the exhibit 4 makes it very clear what his intentions along with J. Rudd and others were. These emails are the proof that they all conspired to push Level Propane to bankruptcy to which John Verbose' 5 cut was 20%. John Verbose created the email account for his partners in crime so they could monitor all the checks and gave them the reports. Other reasons for the account he created included reviewing the company's account to show where the company has lost money. having guest 6 (Pam) show that the company is losing sales and customers. In his email he is clearly aware about Benesch, Friedlander and Associates company but as seen on page 4 of Verbose Depo Part 1 "Okay. And Level at that time was represented by whom? A. They were represented by -- for some reason I just got a mental blank on it", he has answered that he doesn't seem to recall much which shows that he was clearly trying to avoid answering the question. All the emails are exact indicator that he had malicious intent and pushed the level propane company along with his "team" towards bankruptcy. There have been many spoilation arguments stated in the declaration such as the les provided by Mr. Caldwell mostly included email post 2005. About 90% of the hard copy archive library of accounts was missing. Most of the emails had incomplete headers which indicates that the previous emails were deleted. If I was the judge with all these evidences presented to me, I would plead Mr. Verbose guilty as its very clear that Mr. Verbose had master planned the bankruptcy with his team. His avoidance to answer any questions at all just adds more to all the evidence