All of the following indiyiduals can file as head of household EXCEPT:

Joel is a married taxpayer who lives with and provides all of the support for his two children, ages $5$ and $11.$ Joel and his estranged wife have not lived in the same residence for at least two years.

Judy is an unmarried taxpayer who pays all the costs to maintain her home and provides more than half the support for her three$-$year$-$old daughter with whom she lives.

Malcolm is a married taxpayer who lives with and provides more than half the support for his twelve$-$year$-$old daughter. He also provided more than half the cost of maintaining their household. Malcolm's wife moved to New Mexico permanently in April and has had no further contact with the family.

Ralph is a married taxpayer who lives with his mother$-$in$-$law, Millie, and his nine$-$year$-$old daughter in Millie's home. Ralph provides more than half the cost of maintaining the household and provides more than half of his daughter's support. Ralph's wife is in the military. She was deployed all year and intends to move back in with Ralph and the family once her deployment is complete.

Mark for follow up