Question
Annette is a concert violinist who recently constructed a new home and a small recording studio on a quiet back road in Rowan County. The
Annette is a concert violinist who recently constructed a new home and a small recording studio on a quiet back road in Rowan County. The location and quiet nature of the property were important to her because she is a recording artist and a large part of her livelihood depends on the quality of the recordings she produces and sells. To that end, Annette has invested tens of thousands of dollars in high quality, highly sensitive audio recording equipment.
On the day she moved in, Annette saw a sign had been put up on an adjacent property announcing plans by Big Fun, Inc. to build an amusement park there. The sign advertised carnival rides, nightly fireworks, and daily screaming contests. Annettes mother, Beatrice, is enraged because she believes Big Fun will destroy her daughters music career.
The notice also indicated that the permit to build the amusement park had not yet been granted and that a permit hearing was scheduled to take place at the courthouse. Big Fun cant start building the park without the permit.
2. Assume that Annette earns $74,125 per year from her recording business and another $34,500 playing performances at concert halls around the country. Also assume that Big Fun, Inc. is a company headquartered in Indianapolis, Indiana. Though she'd like to sue in federal court, Annette's suit isn't based on any violation of a federal law. Which of the following is true:
1. | Annette can file her suit in federal court solely because she and Big Fun are from different states | |
2. | Annette may not file her suit in federal court because shes not suing under federal law | |
3. | Annettes amount in damages would require her to sue in state court | |
4. | Annette can sue in federal court because federal courts are courts of general jurisdiction |
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started