Answer the below question relating to laws governing business entities

Doctor performed surgery on Perry's spine to insert a metal rod designed by Bolton, Inc.

(Bolton). Shortly after the surgery, Perry developed severe back pain at the location

where the rod was inserted. Within the applicable statute of limitations for a tort action

for negligence, Perry sued Doctor in federal district court, alleging that she was

negligent in using Bolton's rod for the kind of back condition from which he suffered.

Personal jurisdiction, subject matter jurisdiction, and venue were proper.

During a deposition, Perry's attorney asked Doctor to state whether she had performed

any other spine surgeries using Bolton's rods and, if so, whether any of those surgeries

had resulted in complications. Doctor's attorney objected to the questions on the

ground that the information requested had nothing to do with whether Doctor was

negligent as to Perry, and Doctor refused to answer. After the attorneys properly met

and conferred concerning Doctor's refusal, Perry's attorney filed a motion to compel

Doctor to answer the questions.

Shortly after the statute of limitations had run, Perry learned through a newspaper

article that Bolton had been sued by several patients who alleged that they suffered

severe back pain after Bolton's rod was inserted into their spines during surgery. Perry

immediately sought and obtained leave to amend his federal complaint to join and

include a claim against Bolton, alleging that it had negligently designed the rod. Bolton

immediately filed a motion to dismiss Perry's claim against it on the ground that the

statute of limitations had already run.

Perry also learned that Doctor had lost a lawsuit brought by another patient with a back

condition like his who had also alleged negligence by Doctor for inserting Bolton's rod

into his spine. Perry filed a motion for summary judgment against Doctor on the basis

of preclusion.

1. How should the court rule on Perry's motion to compel Doctor to answer? Discuss.

Q2

Explain constant return to scale relating to input output relationship in a firm

Q3

Discuss the distinction between return factor and return to scale