Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
ASSIGNMENT You are asked to research and write a report advising a business on a number of legal and compliance issues. It is highly recommended
ASSIGNMENT You are asked to research and write a report advising a business on a number of legal and compliance issues. It is highly recommended that you make yourself familiar with both the assignment requirements TOPICS and the marking rubric/s which are available on your Moodle site and is also made available at the end of this document. You need to read Chapters 5, 6, 8 and 12 of the prescribed text (along with the lecture slides, tutorial questions, and answers. Research outside the prescribed text is also recommended) Use the problem-solving format (IRAC) in answering questions 1 and 2. QUESTION 1: 10+10 =20 marks Antonio is a scientist who has patented a new process for making Covid-19 anti-viral drugs. On 1 January 2023, Antonio registered a company with ASIC called AV-Covid 19 Pty Ltd. Antonio is the sole shareholder and Managing Director of the company. However, he has ten other scientists working for him. In preparation of the AV drugs, Antonio had signed a contract to buy nirmatrelvir and ritonavir, with Plaxo Tiger Ltd. Under the terms of the contract Plaxo Tiger Ltd would supply 100 kg of both ingredients, a crucial component of the anti-viral drug. The contract specified that both payment and delivery would take place on 31 January. Antonio signed the contract as 'Antonio Braganza, Managing Director, AV-Covid 19 Pty Ltd'. PlaxoTiger Ltd agrees to supply the ingredients in 2 instalments on May 1 and June 30, 2023. The early production of the drug has proved successful, and Antonio needs more capital. Antonio persuades a few relatives to invest in the company and five of his relatives buy large pockets of shares in AV-Covid 19 Pty Ltd. Because Antonio issues a large number of shares, he ends up being a minority shareholder. On 20 February, in a shareholders' meeting, a new board consisting of Susan and Peter and the Managing director, Mamamia is elected. The new board met on 28 February and decides not to proceed with the contract with PlaxoTiger Ltd. The board believes that they can source the ingredients for their product more cheaply from another supplier. AV-Covid 19 Pty Ltd sent a letter to PlaxoTiger Ltd. informing that the company would not proceed with the contract, pay for it, or take delivery of, the nirmatrelvir and ritonavir. PlaxoTiger Ltd insists that AV-Covid 19 Pty Ltd has signed a contract and thus the company is bound by the contract and must pay for the drugs on delivery. On the other hand, AV-Covid 19 Pty Ltd argues that the contract has not been signed by the company, but by Antonio, so he is liable under the contract. AV-Covid 19 Pty Ltd writes a letter to Antonio to pay for the nirmatrelvir and ritonavir and sort out the matter with PlaxoTiger Ltd. In the meantime, Antonio decides to branch off privately into the business of selling firearms for which he needs a licence from the relevant government authority. The legislation prohibits the granting of a licence to 'any person who has a criminal conviction involving threatening to harm others.' Many years ago, when Antonio was a student at the university, he had been convicted of 'threatening to harm' his opponent in the university election. Antonio asks his friend Anthony to form a company, AA Shooters Pty Ltd. Antonio owns 99 shares and his friend, Anthony holds only 1 share. The company appoints Antonio as the Managing Director, and his friend Anthony becomes the Company Secretary. Antonio asks the company to lodge an application with the Firearms Board Victoria for a licence on behalf of the company. AA Shooters Pty Ltd has received a letter from the Firearms Board refusing the licence application. The reason given by the Firearms Board is Antonio's previous criminal conviction of 'threatening to harm others' Antonio approaches you for legal advice in relation to a lawsuit brought against him by Plaxo Tiger Led for breach of contract. AA Shooters Pty Ltd also wishes to challenge the refusal of a licence by the Firearms Board. In answering this question, you should read chapters 5 and 8 of the prescribed textbook.QUESTION 2: 5+5=10 marks Susan, Peter, and Mamamia hold 30% of the shares in AV COVID-19 Pty Ltd and the rest of the shares are held by Antonio and Anthony, 5% each. The company's constitution states that all the company's production requirements must be sourced from a company called DrugRus Lid., a company owned by Antonio's brother. The board members believe that the company's production needs can be sourced from SafeDrug Services Lid, at competitive prices. The company has decided to enter into a contract with SafeDrug Services Ltd rather than with DrugRus Ltd. A shareholders meeting was scheduled to be held in July 2023, but due to an administrative error, Antonio did not receive notice of the meeting. At the meeting, the following resolutions were passed: a. The first was to change the company name from AV COVID-19 Pty Ltd to SPM Pty Ltd. b. The second resolution was to change the company's constitution to allow the company's production needs to be sourced from SafeDrug Services Ltd. Both resolutions were agreed to by three shareholders Susan, Peter and Mamamia in favour and Anthony against the resolution. Antonio did not attend the meeting, as he was not given the notice of the meeting. DrugRus Ltd is threatening to sue AV COVID-19 for the breach of the company's constitution. Can they do so? Antonio is contesting the validity of proceedings at the shareholders' meeting held in July and wishes to challenge the two resolutions in the meeting. On what grounds, if any, Antonio can ask the court to invalidate the resolutions? In answering this question, you should read chapters 6 and 12 of the prescribed textbook. Answer both questions, citing statutory and case law authority
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started