Question
At Boyle's trial, the state demonstrated that Boyle and others had committed a series of bank robber-ies in four states during the 1990s. There was
"At Boyle's trial, the state demonstrated that Boyle and others had committed a series of bank robber-ies in four states during the 1990s. There was a core group involved in all the robberies, but sometimes others would also assist them. The group would meet together before each crime to plan the rob-bery, assign everyone's tasks, and assemble the tools. After each heist, they would divide the pro-ceeds. There was no clear leader, and no overall master plan for a series of robberies.At the trial, the judge told jurors that to estab-lish the existence of an enterprise, the government had to prove that "(1) there [was] an ongoing organization with some sort of framework, formal or informal, for carrying out its objectives; and (2)the various members and associates of the association function[ed] as a continuing unit to achieve a common purpose." The judge also told the jury that it could "find an enterprise where an association of individuals, without structural hierar-chy, [was] form[ed] solely for the purpose of car-rying out a pattern of racketeering acts" and that "[c]ommon sense suggests that the existence of an""association-in-fact is oftentimes more readily proven by what it does, rather than by abstract analysis of its structure."The judge did not give the jury Boyle's requested instruction that the government was required to prove that the enterprise "had an ongoing orga-nization, a core membership that functioned as a continuing unit, and an ascertainable structural hierarchy distinct from the charged predicate acts."After Boyle was convicted of 11 of 12 counts against him, including the RICO counts, and was sentenced to prison, he appealed on grounds that the instructions as to what would constitute proof of an enterprise incorrectly set forth the law. The circuit court affirmed his convictions, and he appealed to the US Supreme Court. How do you think the high court ruled and why?"
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started