Barry's lawyer asked to see a copy of the report that Charlie had prepared. The PCC refused to produce to Barry's lawyer, acopy of Charlie's report.The PCC did however produce a document which consisted of a summary of the things that Charlie was prepared to testify to at the hearing.The hearing proceeded over the objections of Barry and his lawyer and Barry was found guilty of professional misconduct and penalized.

Assume that Barry has contacted you for advice. Using the legal principles learnt in class, identify the legal issues raised on the facts, analyse the legal issues, present advice to him and advise him as to what steps he can take legally in order to challenge the decision made against him.