Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
Can you please read the case study below and include the answers below. This needs to be like a letter to someone. Ethical Dilemma Report
Can you please read the case study below and include the answers below. This needs to be like a letter to someone.
Ethical Dilemma Report Case Study - "Yours is not to question why" Case Study - Yours is not to question why... Reilly M. Karful, a technologist with Slud, Gefl, Owsdown & Hill (SGOH), has spent the last few weeks designing a tank for the wastewater treatment plant for the town of Whiteside, Ontario. It so happens that the existing treatment plant is located inside one room of a pre-engineered metal building, except for the headworks, which consist of a screen. The design that Reilly is proposing includes installing a new tank inside the treatment room and relocating the screen on top of the tank. During a design review, the reviewer, Yvonne Moore-Karful (distant relation to Reilly) of the architectural firm Plansem & Drawsem, notices that sewage plant headworks are covered by National Fire Code (NFC) Section 820, which requires certain areas to be Class I, Division 1 or Class I, Division 2; i.e., "explosion proof." Concerned about the potential problem, Yvonne calls to let Reilly know that moving the screen into the treatment room would require the room to be classified as explosion proof, and she follows up this call with a memo and her notations on the design drawings. Reilly decides to double-check this information and he reviews NFC 820 himself. The code indeed appears to require the headworks and the existing treatment room to be explosion proof. Reilly informs the project manager at SGOH, Dante McWaves, about the matter, and gives him a copy of Yvonne's memo. With Reilly in his office, Dante phones the client, Bull Parker, the town commissioner, to make him aware of Reilly's concerns. Bull happens to be cleaning his shotgun when he gets Dante's call. News of cost increases and delays does not please Bull, and he pointedly reminds Dante that the project is behind-schedule, that Whiteside needs this addition to the wastewater treatment plant to avoid non-compliance with Provincial regulations, and that Whiteside is not a wealthy town. As he trips the action on the shotgun, as if to place a shell in the chamber (Dante hears this over the phone), Bull tells Dante that he'll have the Fire Code Official, Bobby Burns, get back to Dante. Reilly notices the color drain from Dante's face and that his hands visibly shake as he hangs up the phone. Within minutes, the fire code official calls and informs Dante that the existing room is already explosion proof. What luck! The problem is solved and Dante, still pale yet with obvious relief, informs Reilly that he doesn't want to bother Bull with any more problems. Dante then clearly and unequivocally directs Reilly to finish the project. But Reilly is concerned. While Bobby Burns' statement satisfies Dante, Reilly suspects the fire code official could be wrong. Though Reilly has limited experience with fire codes, he has noticed that the electrical sockets, light switches, lighting fixtures, and junction boxes appear normal and don't give the appearance of being explosion proof. While part of him wants to pursue the matter, he also realizes that exploring his doubts about the existing room being explosion proof will not only further stress out Dante, but could result in additional project delays, in Whiteside having to fund an expensive retrofit to bring their existing facility up to code, and in further annoying BullStep by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started