CASE 12.2 Parker v. Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp. Supreme Court of California, 1970. 3 Cal.3d 176,...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
CASE 12.2 Parker v. Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp. Supreme Court of California, 1970. 3 Cal.3d 176, 474 P.2d 689, 89 Cal.Rptr. 737. GREAT THE SEAL OF EUREKA CALIFORNIA THE TE OF FACTS Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. planned to produce a musical, Bloomer Girl, and con- tracted with Shirley MacLaine Parker to play the leading female role. According to the contract, Fox was to pay Parker $53,571.42 per week for fourteen weeks, for a total of $750,000. Fox later decided not to produce. Bloomer Girl and tried to substitute another contract for the existing con- tract. Under the terms of this second contract, Parker would play the lead- ing role in a Western movie for the same amount of money guaranteed by the first contract. Fox gave Parker one week in which to accept the new contract. Parker filed suit in a California state court against Fox to recover the amount of compensation guaranteed in the first contract because, she maintained, the two roles were not at all equivalent. The Bloomer Girl production was a musical, to be filmed in California, and it could not be compared with a "western-type" production that Fox tentatively planned to produce in Australia. When the trial court held for Parker, Fox appealed. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court reviewed the case. ISSUE May Fox's substitute offer of the Western movie contract be used in mitigating the damages ensuing from the breach of the first contract? DECISION No. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment for Parker. REASON The court noted that the "measure of recovery by a wrongfully discharged employee is the amount of salary agreed upon for the period. of service, less the amount which the employer affirmatively proves the employee has earned or with reasonable effort might have earned from other employment. Before projected earnings from other employment opportunities not sought or accepted by the discharged employee can be applied in mitigation, however, the employer must show that the other employment was comparable, or substantially similar, to that of which the employee has been deprived." The court held that the two roles were sub- stantially dissimilar-that is, one called for Parker's dancing and acting. abilities, and the other was simply an acting role in a Western movie. The court asserted that "by no stretch of the imagination" could the latter "be considered the equivalent of or substantially similar to the lead in a song- and-dance production." FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS International Consideration Many legal systems, including that of France, have no clear requirement that dam- ages must be mitigated. Can justice be better served by requiring that damages be mitigated? If so, how? CASE 12.2 Parker v. Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corp. Supreme Court of California, 1970. 3 Cal.3d 176, 474 P.2d 689, 89 Cal.Rptr. 737. GREAT THE SEAL OF EUREKA CALIFORNIA THE TE OF FACTS Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation. planned to produce a musical, Bloomer Girl, and con- tracted with Shirley MacLaine Parker to play the leading female role. According to the contract, Fox was to pay Parker $53,571.42 per week for fourteen weeks, for a total of $750,000. Fox later decided not to produce. Bloomer Girl and tried to substitute another contract for the existing con- tract. Under the terms of this second contract, Parker would play the lead- ing role in a Western movie for the same amount of money guaranteed by the first contract. Fox gave Parker one week in which to accept the new contract. Parker filed suit in a California state court against Fox to recover the amount of compensation guaranteed in the first contract because, she maintained, the two roles were not at all equivalent. The Bloomer Girl production was a musical, to be filmed in California, and it could not be compared with a "western-type" production that Fox tentatively planned to produce in Australia. When the trial court held for Parker, Fox appealed. Ultimately, the California Supreme Court reviewed the case. ISSUE May Fox's substitute offer of the Western movie contract be used in mitigating the damages ensuing from the breach of the first contract? DECISION No. The California Supreme Court affirmed the judgment for Parker. REASON The court noted that the "measure of recovery by a wrongfully discharged employee is the amount of salary agreed upon for the period. of service, less the amount which the employer affirmatively proves the employee has earned or with reasonable effort might have earned from other employment. Before projected earnings from other employment opportunities not sought or accepted by the discharged employee can be applied in mitigation, however, the employer must show that the other employment was comparable, or substantially similar, to that of which the employee has been deprived." The court held that the two roles were sub- stantially dissimilar-that is, one called for Parker's dancing and acting. abilities, and the other was simply an acting role in a Western movie. The court asserted that "by no stretch of the imagination" could the latter "be considered the equivalent of or substantially similar to the lead in a song- and-dance production." FOR CRITICAL ANALYSIS International Consideration Many legal systems, including that of France, have no clear requirement that dam- ages must be mitigated. Can justice be better served by requiring that damages be mitigated? If so, how?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
The concept of mitigation of damages in contract law is aimed at ensuring that the party who suffers a breach of contract takes reasonable steps to minimize their losses In the case of Twentieth Centu... View the full answer
Related Book For
Employment Law for Business
ISBN: 978-1259722332
9th edition
Authors: Dawn D. Bennett Alexander, Laura P. Hartman
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Mitch Company Comparative Balance Sheets December 31 Assets Cash Accounts receivable Inventory Land Equipment Accumulated depreciation-equipment Total Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity Accounts...
-
Based on Westlaw's data on the case Christoff v. Nestl USA, INC., I did the brief case. My question is, is there any need to add and adjust the content and form of the case brief, especially the...
-
Shirley Parker is the legal name of well-known actress Shirley MacLaine, who contracted with Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation to play the female lead in a picture entitled Bloomer Girl, a...
-
Why " Kodak " is unsuccessful in implementing a strategy. Can you prepare a critical examination of the strategy to address the following questions about Kodak. What was the strategy and why do you...
-
Currency volatility is a key determinant of currency option value, but it is not directly observable. In what ways can you estimate currency volatility?
-
Referring to the random variables whose joint density function is given in Exercise 3.41, find the covariance between the weight of the creams and the weight of the toffees in these boxes of...
-
Explain the accounting equation for the statement of cash flows. Explain the three major components reported on the statement of cash flows.
-
Favorite Foods Corp. sold its food to stores and distributors. It established a quantity discount scale that was publicly published and made available to all buyers. The top of the scale gave the...
-
A dietician is planning a snack package of fruit and nuts. Each ounce of fruit will supply zero units of protein, 3 units of carbohydrates, and 2 units of fat, and will contain 40 calories. Each...
-
What is one alternative metric or test for measuring health (other than BMI)? How does it work? When would it be a good indication, and what might it lack? Explain
-
A ball is released from rest at the top of an inclined plane, whose length is d = 140 cm. It takes the ball t = 0.70s to roll down to the bottom of the plane. (a) What is the ball's acceleration down...
-
A lottery offers a $ 1 , 0 0 0 , 0 0 0 prize to be paid in 2 0 equal installments of $ 5 0 , 0 0 0 at the end of each year. What is the future value of this annuity if the current annual rate is 7 %...
-
What is privatization and how is it different than contracting out? In what ways is privatization an effective way of introducing competition into the provision of public services? What are some of...
-
Differentiate. y=7*.log 7x (7x.log 7x) 0g 7x) = dx
-
Given the 4 ratios, and comparing the two years, how would you evaluate the company's profitability and why?Year 2018 2019 Net Income $2,465 $2,300 Revenue $21,965 $22,428 Net profit Margin 11.22%...
-
Manitowoc Crane? (B).??Manitowoc Crane? (U.S.) exports heavycrane equipment to several Chinese dock facilities. Sales arecurrently 15,000 units per year at the yuan equivalent of $21,000eac 0 answers
-
Time Travel Publishing was recently organized. The company issued common stock to an attorney who provided legal services worth $25,000 to help organize the corporation. Time Travel also issued...
-
Describe the types of inventories used by manufacturers and merchandisers.(Appendix)
-
(EAIR with processing fees) Your local bank has offered you a 5-year, $100,000 mortgage. The bank is charging 1.2 points, and the processing fee to be paid immediately is $600. If the interest rate...
-
Compare the flow of inventory costs between merchandisers and manufacturers.(Appendix)
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App