Case: The Best Deal Gillette Could Get? Proctor & Gamble' Acquisition of Gillette

Based on the case, answer the following:

3. Evaluate the P&G offer. Make a list of the positive and negative aspects of receiving shares or cash from both the perspective of P&G and Gillette shareholders.

4. Compare the valuation analyses in Case Exhibits 6 and 7. Why are they different? Support and defend the validity of using each valuation method.