Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
Comment in details on the response. Comment in details on the response. Original Question Our client is the founder of Epsilonia, a highly successful, closely
Comment in details on the response.
Comment in details on the response. Original Question Our client is the founder of Epsilonia, a highly successful, closely held business. He never married or had children, but he did have three sisters, all of whom were active in the company's management and served on the company's Board of Directors. Epsilonia was started over 70 years ago. Prior to 1960, our client was the sole stockholder of Epsilonia. As the company's value grew rapidly, our client became concerned about income taxes and estate taxes. This concern was common in 1960 because the top income tax rate was 91% and the top estate and gift tax was likewise extremely high. Long-term capital gains tax rates were 25%. In 1960, our client retained 40% of Epsilonia stock for himself and placed the remaining 60% of the stock into trust for the benefit of his sisters and their children. The trust said, in relevant part: \"The split-interest trust annually shall distribute trust income to each sister during her life. Upon each sister's death, the principal attributable to her share of the trust shall be distributed in kind to her then-living children.\" Your client remained the sole trustee of the trust during his lifetime. Upon the recent death of our client, his sisters became cotrustees. Due to the generosity of our client to his sisters during his lifetime, each sister is independently wealthy and self-sufficient financially. Epsilonia stock historically has paid a dividend distribution rate equal to only .007% on market value. Two of the three sisters do not mind that Epsilon stock pays such a low dividend because the stock has generated substantial capital appreciation, making each sister's children \"ridiculously rich.\" In fact, the Epsilon stock has appreciated at more than twice the rate of the overall stock market from 1960 to present. However, one of the sisters would like to receive more income for herself and has pleaded with her sisters, as co-trustees, to shift the trust's assets into a High-Income Stock Index Fund that will generate significant dividend income. The other sisters have refused, however. As a result, the aggrieved sister has filed a lawsuit, claiming that, as the income beneficiary of the trust, she is receiving an inadequate amount of money. She contends: * The cotrustees have breached their fiduciary duty of reasonable care by failing to adequately diversify the trust. * The cotrustees have breached their fiduciary duty of impartiality. This duty requires trustees to establish investment policies that give \"due regard\" to the interests of both the income beneficiary and the principal beneficiary in a split interest trust. a. Did the three sisters, as cotrustees, unethically gamble with the trust's wealth by maintaining a concentrated investment ownership position only in Epsilonia stock? b. In this situation, was it unethical for the co-trustees to keep all of the trust's assets invested in a stock that generated such a low dividend that the trust's income beneficiaries barely received any income? Response A. The ethicality of the sisters as trustees maintaining a concentrated investment in Epsilonia stock depends on the trust agreement, the founder's intent, and investment norms. While diversification is typically good, the exceptional performance of Epsilonia stock and possible directives in the trust might justify this approach, especially if it aligns with the founder's wishes. B. The decision to keep all trust assets in a low-dividend stock raises questions about balancing the needs of current income the sisters and future their children. Ethically, the trustees should aim for a balanced investment strategy that provides income and capital growth unless the trust's terms or the founder's intent indicate otherwise. This involves considering both the sisters' immediate income needs and the children's long-term growthStep by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started