Compare and contrast the Christmas Shop Manager and Alaska Packers. How were both cases similar? How were they different? How do you think differences will influence the outcome of the Christmas Shop Manager? Should he win the case and get his job back or lose? Write a paragraph explaining your position and support it using details from these two cases. Since this is the second use of the peer assessment tool, this one will count. When grading, you'll be looking at two criteria: Do you have an opinion on how this case turns out? Do you support your position using enough details? Once you complete the assignment, you will find out how the case turned out and why