critical case comment on any case in constitutional law.

Extended commentary on a particular case that combines both description and analysis

You must analyze the judgment

Begin with a thesis statement / argument

Take a strong position (for example, the case was decided incorrectly because it misapplied or misinterpreted the Constitution; or the Constitution is deficient in some way; or the case was decided correctly but for the wrong reasons; or another argument)

Your argument must be grounded in constitutional law

You may wish to draw on the wider political and social context to assist in explaining and analyzing the case

You may agree with an outcome in a case, but your analysis must be more than just descriptive - you need to make an argument of some kind