Question
Dubious Used Cars received the promissory note shown below from First Auto, Inc., as security for payment of $14000 automobile. When DUC accepted the note,
Dubious Used Cars received the promissory note shown below from First Auto, Inc., as security for payment of $14000 automobile. When DUC accepted the note, it was aware that the maker of the note, Hawley, Inc., was claiming that the note was unenforceable because Able Co. (the original payee) had breached the contract for which Hawley had given the note. First Auto had acquired the note from Smith in exchange for repairing several cars owned by Smith. At the time First Auto received the note, First Auto was unaware of the dispute between Hawley and Able. Also, Smith, who paid Able $3500 for the note, was unaware of Hawley's allegations that Able had breached the agreement.
Promissory Note
Date: 10-12-20
Hawley, Inc. promises to pay to Able or bearer the sum of $14000 on or before May 15, 2022 (maker may elect to extend due date by 30 days) with interest thereon at the rate of 5.5% per annum.
Hawley, Inc.
By: \\\\s\\\\P.J. Hawley
P.J. Hawley, President
Reference: Able contract
And here is the reverse side:
Pay to the order of First Auto without recourse
\\\\s\\\\E. Smith
E. Smith
Pay to the order of Dubious Used Cars.
First Auto
By: \\\\s\\\\G. First
G. First, President.
First Auto is now insolvent and unable to satisfy its obligation to Dubious. Therefore, Dubious has demanded that Hawley pay the $14000, but Hawley has refused, asserting:
a. The note is nonnegotiable because it references the contract and is not payable at a definite time or on demand.
b. Dubious is not a holder in due course because it received the note as security for amounts owed by First Auto.
c. Dubious is not an HDC because it was aware of the dispute between Hawley and Able.
d. Hawley can raise the alleged breach by Able as a defense to payment.
e. Dubious has no right to the note because it was not endorsed by Able.
State whether the assertion is correct and give reasons for your conclusion
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started