Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

ESSAY : Your answer should be in the form of an IRAC. On March 17, 2019, Pepe Morel- the Vice President of Development for Le

ESSAY: Your answer should be in the form of an IRAC.

On March 17, 2019, Pepe Morel- the Vice President of Development for Le Pue SA (a French corporation), contacted Mary Q. Contrary to serve as Le Pue's agent. Le Pue is looking to expand into the American market. While Le Pue is known throughout Europe, they are just now looking to the booming American market. Le Pue was founded fifty years ago and is known for its highly regarded perfumes and colognes. Le Pue is looking to develop a line of scents that cater to American tastes. Le Pue's immediate need is to locate land and a building for their American plant. Mary Q. Contrary is one of the most successful commercial realtors in the Pacific Northwest. Le Pue asks Mary to work on their behalf in locating an appropriate facility in the Seattle area. Le Pue has agreed to pay Mary a monthly salary, provide her with a generous health insurance plan, and a company car. Mary accepts Le Pue's offer.

On March 25, Pepe Morel (on behalf of Le Pue) and Mary Contrary executed a written agreement detailing each party's duties and benefits. Pursuant to the terms of this contract, Mary was given authority to purchase land and a building for up to $1,000,000. Should Mary be unable to find the needed land and building for $1,000,000 or less, then the contract specified that Mary must first contact Pepe for further instructions. Mary's salary was set at $12,500 per month for six months. The contract specified that Mary would receive full medical, dental, vision and disability benefits. Mary would also receive a 2019 Tesla Model X.

On April 2, while driving to view property located in Bellevue, WA, Mary accidentally lost control of her car, which caused her to crash into a 2015 Ford Fiesta driven by Ms. Kitty Odorable. Other than substantial damage to the Tesla, Mary was uninjured. Unfortunately, Ms. Kitty Odorable was seriously injured - both of her legs were broken, there was internal bleeding and a concussion that resulted in a complete loss of memory. After three months of intensive therapy, Ms. Odorable was released from the hospital. At the time of the release, Ms. Odorable's memory was partially restored. It was estimated that Ms. Odorable would need 12 - 15 months of additional out-patient therapy.

On September 1, 2019, Ms. Odorable sued Le Pue SA claiming that LePue is liable based on the legal theory ofvicarious liability (respondeat superior).

Is Le Pue liable for Ms. Odorable's injuries? What is the likely result.

Your analysis should be in the form of an IRAC (please see below). You should explore, in detail, the arguments each party will make. For purposes of this paper, the rule of law for vicarious liability (also known as respondeat superior) is defined as follows:

Respondeat Superior/ vicarious liability:

  1. Absent direct liability, the principal's liability for the agent's torts is heavily dependent on the employee-independent contractor distinction.
  2. A principal is liable for the torts of agents:

1)Who are employees, and

2)Who commit the tort during the scope of their employment.

  1. Scope of employment:

1)Act was the kind the employee was employed to perform,

2)It occurred during authorized working hours,

3)It occurred at authorized location, and

4)It was motivated by the purpose of serving the employer.

Your analysis must be in the form of an IRAC (i.e., Issue; Rule; Application; Conclusion). If you are unfamiliar with the IRAC method, please review the sample essay(s) posted in Canvas, as well as the following IRAC sources:

(1)Microsoft Word - IRAC ANALYSIS-1.pdf(Links to an external site.)

(2) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47W2gqqM54U;

(3) http://youveenteredlawland.com/irac-for-law-school-essays-and-exams/

PLEASE NOTE: THIS ASSIGNMENT MAY BE COMPLETED INDIVIDUALLY OR AS A GROUP. That said, this project is designed to take approximately 30 hours to complete. This includes the time it takes to research, read, write and proofread. Accordingly, I strongly recommend completing the assignment as a group. If you choose to work on this assignment as a group, groups may be as small as two members, but no more than 4 members. You are expected to organize your own group. Each member of the group must submit the same paper. The names of each member of your group must be at the top of the paper (formatted as noted below), and all members agree to receive the same grade.Whether you complete this assignment as a group or individually, you may not discuss any aspect of this assignment with any other person; except, of course, your instructor or a librarian (for assistance with research).

Paper Format:THE PAPER SHOULD BE AT LEAST 1200 WORDS AND NOT MORE THAN 1500 WORDS, DOUBLE SPACED (TIMES NEW ROMAN, 12 POINT FONT).All papers must be uploaded as a Word document. In addition, you must have: (1) A title page, and (2) A bibliography listing all sources consulted. NOTE: The title page and bibliography are not part of the minimum word count.

Outside research isrequired.You must incorporate research fromat least fourscholarlysources (e.g., case-law, statutes, legal journals, etc.). If you are not certain what qualifies as a scholarly source, you may want to consult a college librarian. If you conduct internet research, scholarly sources usually end with a .gov or .edu extension.Popular internet sources (e.g., wikipedia, law firm websites, etc.) do not count as scholarly sources. Such popular sources, however, may be consulted for informational purposes, but may not be cited to or quoted from in the paper. All quotations must be carefully noted.Quotations should also be limited to no more than 10% of the paper.You must incorporate a minimum of four scholarly sources into your analysis. You must cite all relevant sources and make clear the extent to which outside sources were used.Words or ideas that require citation include, but are not limited to, all hard copy or electronic publications.Full blown citations are not necessary, but must contain sufficient information to identify the source (i.e., full name), the author(s) and the date.

In addition to the research sources available through the campus library and other online sources, youMUST EXAMINEeach of the following sources:

1. Vicarious Liability:http://www.law.uh.edu/assignments/spring2013/30114-first.pdf(Links to an external site.)

2. Summary of Restatement of Agency:http://law.scu.edu/wp-content/uploads/BusOrgs_Diamond-F13.pdf(Links to an external site.)

3. Legal Dictionary:https://legaldictionary.net/vicarious-liability/(Links to an external site.)

4. Meyer v. Holley:https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/537/280.html(Links to an external site.)

5. Law Teacher:https://www.lawteacher.net/free-law-essays/commercial-law/vicarious-liability-of-principal-for-acts-of-agent-commercial-law-essay.php

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access with AI-Powered Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Fundamentals of quality control and improvement

Authors: amitava mitra

3rd edition

470226536, 978-1-11849164, 978-0470226537

Students also viewed these Law questions

Question

What must a person do to apply?

Answered: 1 week ago