• Explore theYou Be the Judge -Intellectual Property: Click Here, Get Suedvideos:Case Argument(Links to an external site.)
• ,Defendant Profile(Links to an external site.)
• ,Plaintiff Profile(Links to an external site.)
• ,Defendant Reaction(Links to an external site.)
• ,Plaintiff Reaction(Links to an external site.)
• .

Discuss how you would rule if you were the judge in this case.

• Did Mr. Higgins infringe on Ms. Garner's Patent?
• Is Ms. Garner's patent valid?
• Does Ms. Garner's patent meet the requirements of being novel, non-obvious, and having utility? Explain why or why not.