Fact Pattern

Phoebe Buffay is going to sue Gunther and Central Perk Caf in federal court based on federal question jurisdiction. Gunther is domiciled in Buffalo, New York, which is within the Western District of New York; Central Perk Caf has its principal place of business in Scarsdale, New York, which is in the Southern District of New York. After talking to her friends, Phoebe learned that the Western District of New York has too many cases and the court is backlogged; the soonest Phoebe would be able to take her case to trial would be four years. All of Phoebe's witnesses are located in the Western District of New York. Phoebe lives in Buffalo, which is within the Western District of New York. Phoebe's attorney lives in Scarsdale, which is in the Southern District of New York. The jury pool in Buffalo (the Western District of New York) is plaintiff-friendly, but the judges in Scarsdale (the Southern District of New York) are plaintiff-friendly. In which district should Phoebe file her action?

Prompt

Select a district and defend your answer using only the facts provided. Limit your initial post to one paragraph