Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
For Questions 1 to 5, please read the scenario below carefully. Always Fashion (as the seller) entered into a contract with Forever50, a big fashion
For Questions 1 to 5, please read the scenario below carefully. Always Fashion (as the seller) entered into a contract with Forever50, a big fashion retail store in Singapore (as the buyer), to sell leather gloves and linen shirts, CIF Singapore. The overall value of the contract is relatively low. Always Fashion is a small factory with limited resources, serving primanly its own domestic market. Nonetheless, it has plans to expand its sales into the region. In contrast, Forever5( intends to go for an mitial public offering in the near future. It has a well- established regional logistics team. It does not require the cargo on an urgent basis since it buys from many different factories within the region and have enough stock of gloves and linen shirts to meet customers' demand for the next six months. Always Fashion arranged for the cargo to be shipped to Singapore, on board the MV Speedy, owned by Leaky Inc. Always Fashion is not very familiar with the expon regulations, regional logistics providers and insurance providers. Its owners had selected Leaky Inc., based on a recommendation from family friends. The camage is expected to amive in Singapore three (3) weeks from the date of leaving the port of origin. The cargo of linen shirts was loaded into Hold No. 1, while the cargo of gloves was loaded nto Hold Mo. 2. The master issued a clean bill of lading which was governed by the Hague-Vishy Rules. Independent contractors hired by Leaky Inc. had just completed repairs to the ship prior to the loading of the cargo. As the independent contractors are well-known, expenienced and respected, the master and the crew of MV Speedy trusted them and did not conduct any checks. However, the independent contractors had failed to tighten some of the storm valves of the ship. As a result, seawater started to seep into Hold No. 1. When the crew discovered this, the master deviated to a nearby port to fix the storm wvalves. This resulted in a one-day delay of the ship's arrival at the Singapore port. The master had also confessed to his crew that he was worried about the safety of the route and the deviation, given the increasing number of reported incidents about piracy and tsunamis. He wanted to complete the journey and reach the Singapore port as soon as possible. On arrival at the Singapore port, an inspection of the cargo found that all the linen shirts in Hold No. | were stained, waterlogged and damaged. In addition, while Hold No. 2 was dry, with no evidence of water seepage, the gloves had become mouldy. Question 1 Appraise if there are any possible grounds of action available to Forever50 against Leaky Inc, the owners of MV Speedy, for the damage to the cargo of linen shirts and the cargo of gloves. In your analysis, discuss the burden of proof for Forever50 and Leaky Inc. Conclude whether Forever 50 would likely be successful in its actions. (30 marks) Question 2 Judge whether the deviation made by MV Speedy to the nearest port was justified and whether Forever50 is entitled to substantive damages arising from the deviation. (10 marks) Question 3 Indicate a possible Incoterm@ which may be feasible for both Always Fashion and Forever50, based on the facts in the scenario above. Support your answer with reasons as to why that Incoterm @ would be feasible for both parties. You should provide details relating to the seller's and the buyer's obligations and the passing of risk under that Incoterm ?). Identify two (2) possible reasons why Always Fashion would wish to continue with shipments on CIF terms. (25 marks) Question 4 Apply the principles in marine insurance to determine the appropriate Institute Cargo Clause(s) for the marine cargo insurance to be bought for the cargo, based on the scenario above. Support your analysis with reasons. (15 marks) Question 5 Recommend a feasible dispute resolution method in the event that there is a dispute between Always Fashion and Forever50 in relation to the contract for the sale of gloves and linen shirts. Provide supporting reasons. As part of your analysis, discuss the advantages and disadvantages of your recommended method. (20 marks)
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started