Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Question
1 Approved Answer
From the images attached below, From Work Breakdown Structure as a skeleton for integration pp. 89-91 in the case study book (E-Reserve), do you agree
From the images attached below, From "Work Breakdown Structure as a skeleton for integration" pp. 89-91 in the case study book (E-Reserve), do you agree or disagree with what discussed in the case regarding the levels in WBS and ownership issue? Provide specific reasons. Any example from your experience?
Work Breakdown Structure as a Skeleton for Integration Wilson Clark and Dragan Z. Milosevic Matt: I keep looking at this piece of paper and can't believe my eyes, or I must not understand it. Percy: What paper are you looking at? The one I brought? Matt: Yes, let me check if I understand it well. The sheet of paper I am holding shows the work breakdown structure (WBS) for the timely termination of the Opto-Mechanical group's portion of work for Project Lada (see Figure 5.2). Is that right? Percy: Yes, right.2 These beginning moments of the conversation between Matt Boon, the engineering manager of the Opto-Mechanical Group, and Percy Bedge, project manager of Lada, do not promise much cooperation. Rather, the atmosphere in which this conversation in Matt's office takes place smells of the open conflict and apparent tension between the meeting participants. MICROMANAGEMENT? Matt: Well, on the second page, it shows an estimate of the person-hours and needed calendar time for each of my engineers involved in Project Lada, from now until the end of it. Percy: Yes. That's the termination plan for Lada. What's wrong with it? Matt: I don't want to sound negative, but all of it is wrong-from details to philosophy. Percy: Give me details. Matt: Your Lada planning indicates at what days on the calendar and how much you need each of my guys from Opto-Mechanical Group. That's based 89Figure 5.2 Project Lada WBS for the Opto-Mechanical Group W Project WBS Unclosed Deliverables Unclosed Deliverables of Functional Group 1 of Functional Group n Unclosed Deliverables of Optoel. Group 1 LEVEL 1 LADA Project Opto-Mechanical Design Lada Project Work Breakdown Structure . . . . LEVEL 2 Phase 0 Phase 2 Phase 1 Phase 3 Opto-Mechanical Concept Analysis Design Planning Launch Project Phases LEVEL 3 Inspection & Validate System Validate Validate Verify Mass Opto-Mechanical Acceptance of Shock Projection Lens System Optical Production- Deliverables Tooled Parts Performance to Specification Performance Pilot Build Validate System Validate System Validate Approval to Mechanical Vibration Optical Engine Ship Product Assembly Performance Assemblyon the assumption that they are engaged in work on only one project, and that's your project, Lada. Those are wrong details. As a matter of fact, they are shared among six projects. Since you scheduled them for certain time periods for which they are already scheduled by other projects with higher priorities, those higher-priority projects automatically obtain my guys. Even if you planned properly, there is another issue for which I would not agree with your WBS and related termination plan. I thought we already resolved the ownership issue. You guys, the project management team, own deliverables from the top three levels of the project WBS. And we, the func tional groups, own all deliverables in the lower levelsthe fourth and below. \"We own them\" means we plan them, we execute them, and we control them, which means we monitor and report them to you. You have no right to meddle or control activities on our deliverables, unless we screw up. To remind you, I found the company's PM charter. It shows that this is the current and ruling division of ownership signed-off on by all engineering managers and project management, and senior management. 5 Project Scope Management 91 But you seem to forget or ignore the PM charter, just as you tried to ignore it during Lada's Map Day. With the termination WBS, it appears again that you would like to micromanage us. Percy: I see where you come from. Frankly, my intention was not to micro- manage you. Give me a few days to go over it, and I'll get back to you. Discussion items 1. What are the pros and cons of having many levels of WBS? 2. Do you prefer a few or many levels of WBS? WhyStep by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started