Here is a hard and tricky question...is this commercial speech--in reverse? Check it out: North Carolina's controversial new frackingbillhas been signed by governor. Many republican legislators and governor McCrory himself have ties to the industry and received massive campaign contributions from PAC's and individual gas companies. If you talk negatively about fracking and in the process reveal things the industry wants secret, far beyond the usual trade secret protection, you could go to jail. It's clear from the legislative history of the bill that the gas industry wanted to stop anti-fracking scientists and environmentalists from introducing data on ground water pollution etc.Do citizens or media outlets publishing stories contrary to this law have a palpable First Amendment claim?