I need to respond back my fellow student about this discussion post$-$ what can I say?

Does Mary have a case for reimbursement?:

Yes, Mary likely has a case for reimbursement. She incurred costs and made business decisions based on Janice's request and subsequent cancellation.

Under what legal theory might she prevail and what are her damages, if any?

Mary might prevail under the legal theory of "promissory estoppel." This doctrine applies when:

A promise was made $($Janice requested the wallpapering job$).$

The promisee $($Mary$)$ relied on the promise to her detriment.

The reliance was reasonable and foreseeable.

Injustice can only be avoided by enforcing the promise.

In this case, Mary relied on Janice's promise by ordering the custom wallpaper and blocking off her calendar, incurring costs and potential lost business opportunities. Her damages would include the cost of the wallpaper $($$$5000)$ and any additional expenses related to labor and preparation for the job.

What ethical theories might be applicable?

Several ethical theories can be applied to this scenario:

Utilitarianism: This theory focuses on the greatest good for the greatest number. Janice's cancellation caused significant financial harm to Mary, which could have been avoided with better communication and consideration of the consequences.

Deontological Ethics: This theory emphasizes duties and rules. Janice had a duty to honor her commitment to Mary, especially after Mary had taken significant steps based on that commitment.

Virtue Ethics: This theory focuses on the character and virtues of the individuals involved. Janice's actions could be seen as lacking in virtues such as honesty, reliability, and fairness, while Mary demonstrated diligence and trust.

Mary has a strong case for reimbursement under the legal theory of promissory estoppel, with her damages including the cost of the wallpaper and related expenses. Ethically, Janice's actions can be critiqued from utilitarian, deontological, and virtue ethics perspectives, highlighting the importance of honoring commitments and considering the impact of one's actions on others.

Thanks,