I want to know if I did the problem correctly. Thank you if you can check my work.
Attachment: Data.xls (All dollar values in millions) B We would need to immediately approve a capital allocation of $1.70 million to jump-start the project. In addition, we would need to capitalize another $20.5 million almost equally for the next three years. These expenses will be incurred on an after-tax basis. The first year of the project is unlikely to bring any additional revenues, but from second year, we should see revenues increase by $1.800 million. Our preliminary estimates also show revenues growing to $9.700 million in year 2, $19.300 million in year 3, $22.800 million in year 4, and $24.600 million in year 5. 2 Capitalized expenses $20.5 (spread over 3 years) $3.400 Non-cash(depreciable) expenses Operating costs as a percentage of revenues I am also attaching some information the team used for the cash flow valuation. See you later to go over the numbers. Year 1: 141% Year 2: 33% Year 3: 22% Year 4: 22% Year 5: 24% Cheers, Dikran 5 | Taxes 40% The analysts on the team created pro forma estimates of the expected cash flows that the project is likely to generate and also discussed some assumptions: Complete the following cash flow analysis based on the information provided. Express all values in millions of dollars and round all values to three decimal places. Year O 0 1.700 Year 1 1.800 2.538 Year 2 Year 3 9.700 | 19.300 3.201 4.246 Year 4 22.800 5.016 Year 5 24.600|| 5 .904) 3.400 3.400 3.400 3.400 3.400 3.400, | -5,100 -4.138 3.099 11.654 14.384 15.296 Revenue estimates are based on the expectation of a higher price point resulting from a more robust product. Operating expenses include internal labor, maintenance, overhead expense, and cost avoidance from being able to ramp down spending on existing platforms. The capitalized expenses include the costs of platform development, content creation, internal and external labor, computers, facility investment, and so on. These expenses are amortizable and depreciable over the first three of the six years of the project's expected life. They are recognized separately from the normal depreciation and amortization expenses. These capital expenses will be deducted from the project's annual cash flow from operations to derive at the project's total expected cash flows. Revenues Less: Operating expenses Less: Depreciation & Amortization Operating Income Less: Tax Plus: Non-cash expenses Operating Cash Flow Less: Capitalized expenses Total Cash Flow -2.040 3.400 -1.655 3.400 1.240 3.400 4.662 3.400 5.754 3.400 6.118 3.400 0.340 0.917 5.259 10.392 12.030|| 12.578 7.300 6.600 6.600 -6.960 -5.683 -1.341 10.392 12.030 12.578 The finance team got together to discuss the financing costs of the project. The following is an excerpt of their discussion. Read the dialogue and fill in the missing word or words. Dikran Should we use the company's WACC or use the beta of a comparable project when applying a cost of capital to this project? Sanford We calculate our WACC on an annual basis based on the company's capital structure for the fiscal year. All of our investments are treated as cash investments so that we can fairly compare all initiatives based on their value proposition. This is a one-of-a-kind project in the ed tech space, and we believe that it will drive incremental revenues and contribute to the preservation of revenue for Cengage's existing products. The project also seems to align with the reinvestment objectives of our private equity owners. Dikran Sounds good. We also calculate our applicable tax rates annually, and considering the digital landscape of this project, we would not necessarily need to use different tax rates based on the different states in which we operate. I guess it is fair to apply a standard tax rate in the valuation of the project cash flows. Sanford Let's use our standard WACC of 12%. I'll see you soon to discuss the valuation of the project. Project Evaluation The Accept/Reject Recommendation The analysts in the team run the numbers and hand over the evaluation to Sanford. Complete the data in the report. (Note: Round all values to two decimal places, except for the IRR value which should be rounded to the nearest integer.) The project proposal with supporting data was presented to the CFO and the board. After discussion and scrutiny of the assumptions in the report, the board is most likely to accept the project because of which of the following reasons? Check all that apply. Year -$6.96 $9.09 Year 1 -$5.07 Year 2 -$1.07 Year 3 $7.40 Year 4 $7.65 Year 5 $7.14 PV of cash flows NPV of the project IRR of the project Payback period 31% - - - - O The management team believes that this project will lead the transition toward becoming a digital-first company. x The project has a positive NPV. Management feels positive about the project, and their instincts say to go for it." X Management believes that the project will help in increasing market share and protect existing penetration. 3.30 years Attachment: Data.xls (All dollar values in millions) B We would need to immediately approve a capital allocation of $1.70 million to jump-start the project. In addition, we would need to capitalize another $20.5 million almost equally for the next three years. These expenses will be incurred on an after-tax basis. The first year of the project is unlikely to bring any additional revenues, but from second year, we should see revenues increase by $1.800 million. Our preliminary estimates also show revenues growing to $9.700 million in year 2, $19.300 million in year 3, $22.800 million in year 4, and $24.600 million in year 5. 2 Capitalized expenses $20.5 (spread over 3 years) $3.400 Non-cash(depreciable) expenses Operating costs as a percentage of revenues I am also attaching some information the team used for the cash flow valuation. See you later to go over the numbers. Year 1: 141% Year 2: 33% Year 3: 22% Year 4: 22% Year 5: 24% Cheers, Dikran 5 | Taxes 40% The analysts on the team created pro forma estimates of the expected cash flows that the project is likely to generate and also discussed some assumptions: Complete the following cash flow analysis based on the information provided. Express all values in millions of dollars and round all values to three decimal places. Year O 0 1.700 Year 1 1.800 2.538 Year 2 Year 3 9.700 | 19.300 3.201 4.246 Year 4 22.800 5.016 Year 5 24.600|| 5 .904) 3.400 3.400 3.400 3.400 3.400 3.400, | -5,100 -4.138 3.099 11.654 14.384 15.296 Revenue estimates are based on the expectation of a higher price point resulting from a more robust product. Operating expenses include internal labor, maintenance, overhead expense, and cost avoidance from being able to ramp down spending on existing platforms. The capitalized expenses include the costs of platform development, content creation, internal and external labor, computers, facility investment, and so on. These expenses are amortizable and depreciable over the first three of the six years of the project's expected life. They are recognized separately from the normal depreciation and amortization expenses. These capital expenses will be deducted from the project's annual cash flow from operations to derive at the project's total expected cash flows. Revenues Less: Operating expenses Less: Depreciation & Amortization Operating Income Less: Tax Plus: Non-cash expenses Operating Cash Flow Less: Capitalized expenses Total Cash Flow -2.040 3.400 -1.655 3.400 1.240 3.400 4.662 3.400 5.754 3.400 6.118 3.400 0.340 0.917 5.259 10.392 12.030|| 12.578 7.300 6.600 6.600 -6.960 -5.683 -1.341 10.392 12.030 12.578 The finance team got together to discuss the financing costs of the project. The following is an excerpt of their discussion. Read the dialogue and fill in the missing word or words. Dikran Should we use the company's WACC or use the beta of a comparable project when applying a cost of capital to this project? Sanford We calculate our WACC on an annual basis based on the company's capital structure for the fiscal year. All of our investments are treated as cash investments so that we can fairly compare all initiatives based on their value proposition. This is a one-of-a-kind project in the ed tech space, and we believe that it will drive incremental revenues and contribute to the preservation of revenue for Cengage's existing products. The project also seems to align with the reinvestment objectives of our private equity owners. Dikran Sounds good. We also calculate our applicable tax rates annually, and considering the digital landscape of this project, we would not necessarily need to use different tax rates based on the different states in which we operate. I guess it is fair to apply a standard tax rate in the valuation of the project cash flows. Sanford Let's use our standard WACC of 12%. I'll see you soon to discuss the valuation of the project. Project Evaluation The Accept/Reject Recommendation The analysts in the team run the numbers and hand over the evaluation to Sanford. Complete the data in the report. (Note: Round all values to two decimal places, except for the IRR value which should be rounded to the nearest integer.) The project proposal with supporting data was presented to the CFO and the board. After discussion and scrutiny of the assumptions in the report, the board is most likely to accept the project because of which of the following reasons? Check all that apply. Year -$6.96 $9.09 Year 1 -$5.07 Year 2 -$1.07 Year 3 $7.40 Year 4 $7.65 Year 5 $7.14 PV of cash flows NPV of the project IRR of the project Payback period 31% - - - - O The management team believes that this project will lead the transition toward becoming a digital-first company. x The project has a positive NPV. Management feels positive about the project, and their instincts say to go for it." X Management believes that the project will help in increasing market share and protect existing penetration. 3.30 years
