Imagine that you were a member of the jury that heard the Ancheff case. Would you have concluded that John Ancheff was in a research study? 

What pieces of information would have been most important in reaching your decision? 

What is the relevance of the fact that the hospital was continuing to collect information on each patient who got the higher dose of the drug and putting that information in a file separate from the patient's medical records? 

What about the fact that the physicians responsible for the program were publishing and lecturing about the results