Question
In recent months, Brown Family Farming Pty Ltd experienced a lot of internal friction between the company's ten (10) shareholders. You have been called in
In recent months, Brown Family Farming Pty Ltd experienced a lot of internal friction between the company's ten (10) shareholders. You have been called in to help identify possible causes of action that would help aggrieved members seek legal relief for breaches of general law and/or statutory rules aimed at protecting minority members against harmful conduct of majority shareholders.
Case Study: Brown Family Farming Pty Ltd (BFF) was registered in 2010 by the Brown family for the purpose of managing the family's successful farming business. According to ASIC records, each of the ten family members (6 brothers and 4 first cousins) are registered as equal shareholders and directors in BFF. Furthermore, due to a restriction in the company constitution, shareholders are prevented from selling or transferring their shares in BFF to anyone outside the remaining shareholders.
Although the family members have not always agreed on everything, they have always allowed each member to participate equally in all company and business decisions. However, since mid-2020, the four cousins learned that the Brown brothers used the Covid lockdowns as an excuse to improperly exclude their cousins from attending board meetings and participate in managing the company's affairs.
Furthermore, the four cousins recently learned that two of the Brown brothers (Sam and Neil Brown), used $50,000 of company funds to make unauthorised investments in high risk shares on behalf of the company (which ultimately failed). To make matters worse, Sam and Neil persuaded their four brothers to forgive the $50,000 loss, claiming that Sam and Neil 'were only trying to help'. As a result, the cousins are unable to stand up to the 6 Brown brothers who, as a majority, refuse to take legal action against Sam and Neil to compensate the company for the money they lost.
Required:
- Advise the four Brown cousins about possible common law and statutory causes of action that would help them stand up to the majority shareholders. For each suggested legal action, also suggest related legal remedies. You must refer to relevant case law and sections in the Corporations Act. You must explain how each cause of action will impact and help the four cousins. (16 marks)
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started