Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

In this assignment, you are asked to further explore the key concepts introduced in the coursethus far. You are asked to write short response paper

In this assignment, you are asked to further explore the key concepts introduced in the coursethus far. You are asked to write short response paper to the case incident: "Case DiscussionQuestions" #2, 3, 4 AND 6 on page 107 (5th Edition) or page 110 (6th Edition) or page 111 (7thEdition).General paper guidelines:1. Papers should be 4-5 pgs in length, tOutside sources do not need to beused, but you need to properly reference the course text.3. Papers should be free of spelling and grammatical errors.4. Papers should be presented in a logical, organized manner.5. Papers should make use of several course concepts.6. Course concepts used should be discussed in context with the case.

image text in transcribedimage text in transcribed
CASE STUDY VICTIM OF DISCRIMINATION? Marita Smith works as a data entry clerk in a government department that is under- going downsizing. Smith, who is severely hearing-impaired, has been a productive employee in her department for the last five years. Her performance has always been above average. Smith has received notice that her position is being eliminated as part of the downsizing. Under her union's contract, she must be given preference for any gov- emment job for which she is qualified. She must be given the job at the expense of other workers, even those already in the position, who may have less seniority. This practice is known as \"bumping.\" Smith has been invited to apply for a term position in another government department, which is converting archival data from paper to an electronic database. To qualify for the position, Smith will have to pass an interview, a timed typing test, an accuracy test that involves accuracy in transcribing information from a computer screen, and another accuracy test that involves fol- lowing written instructions to enter written records into the computer database. These are the same tests that all candidates for the position have had to pass to become eligible for the job. Smith was interviewed one week prior to being administered the three skill tests. The interview protocol followed a standardized form used by all government depart- ments. The three skill tests were administered to groups of nine applicants each. The applicants were seated at desks with computers, which were arranged in three rows of three desks each. The instructions for the tests were given verbally by the test administrator. Smith was provided with the services of a sign language interpreter during the testing and interview sessions. Smith passed the interview but failed the skill tests. Her scores are presented in Table 3.5, along with the minimum scores that had to be obtained on each test to receive a job offer. Based on her performance on the tests, Smith did not receive an offer for the job and was laid off when her current job ended. Smith now believes that she was the victim of discrimination based on her physical disability; she claims that during the interview many references were made to her disability and that the inter- viewer always addressed questions to the sign language interpreter and never made eye contact with her. She feels that she was at a disadvantage in taking the skills tests. prospective employer claims that had she passed the tests she would have w=d and her disability would have been accommodated. The employer argues sesting standards were reasonably necessary for the efficient performance of The standards in Table 3.5 are being justified as bona fide occupational ts (BFORs). Smith has now filed a complaint with her provincial human \"ommission. S ~ Should Smith have received a job offer? Why or why not? (In answering this and the following questions, base your arguments on the court cases presented in this chapter.) Was Smith the victim of discrimination because of her disability? Did she receive appropriate accommodation? _ Are the employer's standards defensible as a BFOR? = Based on the material presented in this chapter, do you think the human nghts commission will support her claim of discrimination? 1 vou were the employer's legal counsel, how would you defend the employer at a human rights tribunal that is called to hear Smith's complaint? What would you advise your client to do with respect to the charge

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image

Step: 3

blur-text-image

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Trusts Law

Authors: Charlie Webb, Tim Akkouh

5th Edition

113760672X, 978-1137606723

More Books

Students also viewed these Law questions

Question

Prepare a statement of cost of goods manufactured. LO.1

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

Always show respect for the other person or persons.

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

Self-awareness is linked to the businesss results.

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

1. Too reflect on self-management

Answered: 1 week ago