Question
Introduction: Hannah Inc. (Hannah) is interested in changing suppliers for its casted Bronze components (Items 001-034 below). Two potential suppliers (Cotton and Peanut) have been
Introduction: Hannah Inc. (Hannah) is interested in changing suppliers for its casted Bronze components (Items 001-034 below). Two potential suppliers (Cotton and Peanut) have been identified and sent a request for proposal (RFP). Both Cotton and Peanut have submitted their completed RFPs (Below) and are waiting to hear back from Hannah.
1. What is the savings opportunity being offered by each supplier?
A. Peanut
B. Cotton
2. Which item has the highest potential savings and which prospective supplier is the quote from?
3. After reviewing all of the available data, what recommendation would you give to the sourcing team? Please explain.
Below is current supplier data
Incumbent Supplier | Item Number | Plant Location | Volume | Price/Unit |
ABC Co. | 001 | Mexico City, Mexico | 3,417,000 | 0.21010 |
ABC Co. | 002 | Mexico City, Mexico | 6,825,600 | 0.28200 |
ABC Co. | 003 | Mexico City, Mexico | 7,497,000 | 0.21630 |
ABC Co. | 004 | Mexico City, Mexico | 15,517,000 | 0.08070 |
ABC Co. | 005 | Dallas, Texas | 16,860,043 | 0.06198 |
ABC Co. | 006 | Mexico City, Mexico | 15,336,000 | 0.06560 |
ABC Co. | 007 | Mexico City, Mexico | 3,269,400 | 0.28200 |
ABC Co. | 008 | Mexico City, Mexico | 3,226,629 | 0.23200 |
ABC Co. | 009 | Mexico City, Mexico | 9,880,000 | 0.09590 |
ABC Co. | 010 | Dallas, Texas | 11,501,237 | 0.04548 |
ABC Co. | 011 | Dallas, Texas | 58,501,369 | 0.00372 |
ABC Co. | 012 | Dallas, Texas | 10,206,964 | 0.02433 |
ABC Co. | 013 | Dallas, Texas | 15,960,405 | 0.03224 |
ABC Co. | 014 | Mexico City, Mexico | 20,979,000 | 0.01910 |
ABC Co. | 015 | Mexico City, Mexico | 9,180,000 | 0.03410 |
ABC Co. | 016 | Mexico City, Mexico | 14,190,000 | 0.01930 |
ABC Co. | 017 | Dallas, Texas | 60,000 | 0.37438 |
ABC Co. | 018 | Mexico City, Mexico | 766,500 | 0.09690 |
ABC Co. | 019 | Mexico City, Mexico | 195,000 | 0.41040 |
ABC Co. | 020 | Mexico City, Mexico | 210,000 | 0.41040 |
ABC Co. | 021 | Dallas, Texas | 849,080 | 0.12750 |
ABC Co. | 022 | Dallas, Texas | 1,661,835 | 0.12735 |
ABC Co. | 023 | Mexico City, Mexico | 665,000 | 0.08250 |
ABC Co. | 024 | Dallas, Texas | 5,226,609 | 0.03118 |
ABC Co. | 025 | Mexico City, Mexico | 158,690 | 0.29980 |
ABC Co. | 026 | Mexico City, Mexico | 985,000 | 0.03750 |
ABC Co. | 027 | Dallas, Texas | 2,313,700 | 0.00416 |
ABC Co. | 028 | Mexico City, Mexico | 64,800 | 0.44600 |
ABC Co. | 029 | Mexico City, Mexico | 240,000 | 0.09240 |
ABC Co. | 030 | Mexico City, Mexico | 800,000 | 0.02680 |
ABC Co. | 031 | McMinville, Tenessee | 2,435 | 9.73310 |
ABC Co. | 032 | Mexico City, Mexico | 143,065 | 0.03950 |
ABC Co. | 033 | Mexico City, Mexico | 120,000 | 0.03830 |
ABC Co. | 034 | Mexico City, Mexico | 102,967 | 0.02410 |
Below is Cotton data
Cotton | ||
Location: China | ||
Payment Terms: 1% 30, Net 60 | ||
Lead Time: 45 days |
Item # | Price ($USD) |
001 | 0.219 |
002 | 0.061 |
003 | 0.270 |
004 | 0.097 |
005 | 0.043 |
006 | 0.053 |
007 | 0.265 |
008 | 0.089 |
009 | 0.090 |
010 | 0.045 |
011 | 0.001 |
012 | 0.017 |
013 | 0.136 |
014 | 0.001 |
015 | 0.062 |
016 | 0.012 |
017 | 0.533 |
018 | 0.043 |
019 | 0.800 |
020 | 0.800 |
021 | 0.207 |
022 | 0.046 |
023 | 0.079 |
024 | 0.023 |
025 | 0.301 |
026 | 0.072 |
027 | 0.022 |
028 | 0.070 |
029 | 0.140 |
030 | 0.146 |
031 | 2.275 |
032 | 0.086 |
033 | 0.016 |
034 | 0.196 |
Below is Peanut Data
Peanut | ||
Location: Mexico | ||
Payment Terms: 2% 10, Net 30 | ||
Lead Time: 15 days |
|
Item # | Price ($USD) |
001 | 0.198 |
002 | 0.134 |
003 | 0.496 |
004 | 0.082 |
005 | 0.023 |
006 | 0.015 |
007 | 0.048 |
008 | 0.137 |
009 | 0.114 |
010 | 0.016 |
011 | 0.010 |
012 | 0.003 |
013 | 0.011 |
014 | 0.052 |
015 | 0.060 |
016 | 0.054 |
017 | 0.013 |
018 | 0.024 |
019 | 0.422 |
020 | 0.042 |
021 | 0.028 |
022 | 0.027 |
023 | 0.161 |
024 | 0.010 |
025 | 0.219 |
026 | 0.006 |
027 | 0.133 |
028 | 0.175 |
029 | 0.150 |
030 | 0.063 |
031 | 1.647 |
032 | 0.040 |
033 | 0.034 |
034 | 0.000 |
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started