Joe bought a video recorder from Abu. Shortly afterwards, he was approached by Mona who claim

that the recorder belonged to her and demanded Joe to surrender the unit. On enquiry Joe came to

know the following facts. Abu had bought the recorder from com video Bhd a dealaer and repairer

in video recorders. Abu paid Com video by cheque but the cheque was dishonoured by the bank

three days later. Com video had informed the police about the matter, but in the mean time Abu

sold the recorder to Joe. However, prior to the sale to Abu, Com Video had infact already sold the

unit to Mona. But Mona could not immediately collect it as some adjustment needed to be made to

it by Com Video on Mona's request.

Advise Joe and Mona as to theirlegal position.

Joe bought recorder from abu, abu bought from com video by cheque but the cheque dishonoured

Whether Abu has a good title