Last semester, a student in my class posed the following question.She opened her mailbox at school and found an issue of Garden & Gun.Suppose that she keeps receiving the magazine for months, and then receives a bill.She refuses to pay the bill, and is sued in Small Claims Court or to make it more interesting, on Judge Judy.

[1] On what basis will the magazine company argue that the student is obligated to pay the bill?

[2] On what basis will the student argue that she is not obligated?

[3] Who wins?Please explain fully.