Question
Lee is a successful chemical engineer with expertise in petroleum products. In November 2020, upon request by, and as a favour to, his friend Alex,
Lee is a successful chemical engineer with expertise in petroleum products. In November 2020, upon request by, and as a favour to, his friend Alex, Lee became a non-executive director of NSW Service Stations Ltd, a company which owned and operated a number of services stations in New South Wales. Alex is the managing director of the company. By agreement, Lee did not take a director's fee for sitting on the board of NSW Service Stations Ltd. Lee rarely attended board meetings and relies on Alex, who has qualifications in accounting, for information about the financial affairs of NSW Service Stations Ltd. Lee explained to Alex that he saw his role as non-executive director to be confined to "planning and policy-making" and, besides, Lee also said to Alex that "I'm an expert in chemical engineering, not in financial matters." Over a period of twelve months, from February 2020 to February 2021, NSW Service Stations Ltd experienced several episodes of cash flow shortages in its business operations. In March 2021, a liquidator is appointed to NSW Service Stations Ltd. The company has suffered loss in excess of a million dollars. An investigation of the affairs of NSW Service Stations Ltd by the liquidator found the following: that NSW Service Stations Ltd had to replace petrol pumps at a net cost of over $800,000 due to the board's decision to import these items, from Techno Pty Ltd, which were non-complaint with Australian safety standards. The company's contract with Techno Pty Ltd was in the sum of $400,000. An independent expert's report to the Board had earlier recommended, in preference, the purchase of locally manufactured petrol pumps which complied with Australian standards. Alex is a major shareholder in Techno Pty Ltd; that the interim financial accounts presented at the monthly Board meeting in December 2020 correctly indicated a cash flow problem. The minutes of the meeting records Lee's attendance at this meeting.
The liquidator seeks your advice as to whether any legal action may be taken against Lee and/or Alex to recover money as a result of a breach of their duties as directors of NSW Service Stations Ltd, other than arising out of insolvent trading, under: a) general law and b) pursuant to the Corporations Act
Your answer should also advise the liquidator of NSW Service Stations Ltd as to his chance of success for probable cause(s) of action identified.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started