Magna Charter has been asked to operate a Beaver bush plane for a mining company exploring north and west of Fort Liard. Magna will have a firm 1-year contract with the mining company and expects that the contract will be renewed for the 7-year duration of the exploration program. Magna has the following choices:

Purchase a plane for $1,000,000

Arrange for a 7-year operating lease from Stellar Leasing Company. Maintenance and insurance will be borne by Magna. Lease payments will be of equal amounts each year, and due in advance at the beginning of each year.

The plane falls in the 5-year class with respect to depreciation under the MACRS. Accordingly, the depreciation percentages are 20%, 32%, 19%, 12%, 11% and 6% respectively. The salvage value at the end of 7 years is estimated at $50,000.

Magnas pre-tax cost of debt is 10%. Magna has large tax-loss carry forwards; however, owing to AMT (Alternative Minimum Tax) provisions, its expected marginal tax rate is 20%. Stellar Leasing Co., on the other hand , is a highly profitable company and faces a marginal tax rate of 40%. Stellar can earn a pre-tax rate of return of 10% on investments of similar risk.

Evaluate the lease from the point of view of both Magna and Stellar assuming that the lease payment is $180,500. What is the range of lease payment that would acceptable from the Lessee and the Lessors view point.