Make-or-Buy, Traditional Analysis, Qualitative Considerations

Apollonia Dental Services is part of an HMO that operates in a large metropolitan area. Currently, Apollonia has its own dental laboratory to produce two varieties of porcelain crownsall porcelain and porcelain fused to metal. The unit costs to produce the crowns are as follows:

	All Porcelain				Porcelain Fused to Metal
Direct materials		$190				$80
Direct labor		50				20
Variable overhead		25				5
Fixed overhead		60				40
Total		$325				$145

Fixed overhead is detailed as follows:

Salary (supervisor)	$30,000
Depreciation	8,000
Rent (lab facility)	22,000

Overhead is applied on the basis of direct labor hours. The rates above were computed using 8,000 direct labor hours. No significant non-unit-level overhead costs are incurred.

A local dental laboratory has offered to supply Apollonia all the crowns it needs. Its price is $265 for all-porcelain crowns and $145 for porcelain-fused-to-metal crowns; however, the offer is conditional on supplying both types of crownsit will not supply just one type for the price indicated. If the offer is accepted, the equipment used by Apollonias laboratory would be scrapped (it is old and has no market value), and the lab facility would be closed. Apollonia uses 2,500 all-porcelain crowns and 1,000 porcelain-fused-to-metal crowns per year.

Required: 1. Should Apollonia continue to make its own crowns, or should they be purchased from the external supplier? Should purchase from an external supplier What is the dollar effect of purchasing? Net savings: 12,000 2. Which of the listed items is not a qualitative factor that Apollonia should consider in making this decision? Savings achieved through purchase from outside supplier 3. Suppose that the lab facility is owned rather than rented and that the $22,000 is depreciation rather than rent. What effect does this have on the analysis in Requirement 1? It decreases the cost of making the crowns to 22,000 X 4. Refer to the original data. Assume that the volume of crowns is 5,000 all porcelain and 2,000 porcelain fused to metal. Should Apollonia make or buy the crowns? Should make its own crowns