Question
Marie is in her early 20s and passionate about climate change. Her protest methods involve vandalism, property damage, trespass, and unlawful entry, and this is
Marie is in her early 20s and passionate about climate change. Her protest methods involve vandalism, property damage, trespass, and unlawful entry, and this is well known to her friends. One day, Marie visits her friend Dave who is an apprentice locksmith, and tells him that she lost her electronic keycard, and that her work will be furious, but she's managed to borrow one from a friend and just needs him to duplicate a copy. Dave has equipment that would be able to duplicate the card.
Dave says, "I thought you were working at the caf. Did you get a new job?"
Marie replies, "I always have a job, Dave. My job is social justice."
Dave recognises that the keycard and code is for the NT Supreme Court, and asks Marie, "Hey, what's this really about?"
Marie says, "One day your kids will ask you what you did to save the world. What kind of answer do you want to give them? Anyway, you know I never hurt anyone."
Dave agrees to duplicate the keycard.
That night, Marie and her friend Ruth use the keycard to sneak into the Supreme Court where a controversial mining project has recently been heard. Ruth owns the sharehouse where Marie lives and is effectively her landlord. Marie has a can of spray paint and they have a plan to spray paint the words 'Climate justice?' on the walls in the foyer. However, when they get to the court building, while they are still in the public area outside the building, Marie decides the whole plan is too risky and they'll get caught.
Ruth is not happy about this and tells Marie that if she's not committed to this she doesn't want her living in the house anymore. She threatens to kick Marie out. Marie has had a lot of trouble finding safe, stable accommodation and is seriously worried about being homeless again. Marie decides not to risk it. She uses the keycard to open the door to the Supreme Court. Once inside, Marie assists Ruth to spray paint a 'Hitler' moustache on the portrait of the judge who made the decision and spray paint the words 'Carbon fascist' on the wall underneath.
This question should be read in conjunction with Question 3.
- Marie has been arrested and charged under s 221 of the NTCC. She would like to apply for bail. Provide Marie with advice regarding the prospects of a successful application for bail. Note that you must refer ONLY to provisions of the NTCC, the Bail Act 1982, and the Weapons Control Act 2001 (if relevant)covered in this course. Any references to other laws will be marked wrong:
- Marie asks what would happen if she pleaded guilty to s 221 of the NTCC. Provide Marie with advice regarding the likely outcome of a sentencing process. If you do not have key information, identify the further information that you would need, why it is legally relevant, and how it might affect the sentencing outcome. Note that you must refer ONLY to provisions of the NTCC and the Sentencing Act 1995. Any references to other laws will be marked wrong.
- If Marie pleads not guilty, would you advise Marie to give evidence in her defence? Justify your answer.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started