Question
Megan Jones retired last May from her old firm, Jones and Associates, an accounting partnership that she had founded with her brother some twenty years
Megan Jones retired last May from her old firm, Jones and Associates,
an accounting partnership that she had founded with her brother some
twenty years ago.
After a year or so at home, Megan grew tired of being out of the loop at
the firm.Soon after this, Megan attended an open house event at Jones
and Associates one evening. During the event she chatted with her former
partners, some clients and several prospective clients who were in
attendance.
Throughout this event, Megan's former partners introduced her to
prospective clients, calling her, "My partner, Ms. Jones," extolling her
experience and expertise.Megan said nothing to contradict these
statements. Rather, she simply smiled and greeted the prospective clients
with social pleasantries and answered questions about herself and her
work.
Theresa was a prospective client who was introduced to Megan in this
manner by several of the firm's partners. Theresa contracted with the firm
to do tax work for her business, expressly relying upon Megan's being a
partner in doing so and understanding that she would be working on her tax
issues.
Jones and Associates failed to perform according to the contract the
firm had with Theresa. Theresa files a lawsuit against the partners of Jones
and Associates and Megan based on their alleged breach of contract.
Along with her answer to Theresa's complaint, Megan's attorney files a
motion to dismiss her from the lawsuit, stating that she is not a partner to
the firm and therefore owes no duty to Theresa. Theresa's attorney files a
response, contending that her client reasonably relied upon the partners'
representations that Megan was a partner and would be performing work
on her tax issues and arguing that she should not be dismissed at this time.
Would you grant Megan's motion to dismiss or would you overrule her
motion, leaving Megan in the lawsuit at this stage of the case.
Please explain the basis for your answer.
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access with AI-Powered Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started