Question
Megan owns and operates a used boat business in Gary, Indiana. Last Spring, she sold a 2020 MasterCraft NXT boat to Connor, a resident of
Megan owns and operates a used boat business in Gary, Indiana. Last Spring, she sold a 2020 MasterCraft NXT boat to Connor, a resident of Chicago, Illinois. She also sold a 2017 Four Winns 200H/SS boat to Andy, who lives in South Bend, Indiana. Unknown to Connor and Andy, Megan had removed the factory stereo systems from both boats and replaced them with cheaper aftermarket models.
When Conner was driving his boat on July 4, the radio in his MasterCraft malfunctioned and emitted a loud screeching noise. Connor was startled and looked away from the water. He crashed the MasterCraft into a dock and was severely injured, incurring medical bills in excess of $90,000. On the same day, Andy discovered the switched-out stereo. He determined that the stereo in the boat is worth $400 less than the factory model that is usually installed in a 2017 Four Winns 200H/SS Boat. Both Connor and Andy plan to individually sue Megan.
Based on the information above, determine if the following Courts have subject matter jurisdiction and explain in detail and thoroughly why or why not.
- Can Connor sue Megan in Illinois Federal District Court?
- Can Connor sue Megan in Illinois state trial courts?
- Can Andy sue Megan in Indiana Federal District Court?
- Can Andy sue Megan in Indiana state trial courts?
- Can Andy sue Megan in the Indiana State Court of Appeals?
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Step: 1
Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions
See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success
Step: 2
Step: 3
Ace Your Homework with AI
Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance
Get Started