Murdock was injured using a lawnmower produced by Obewon Lawnmower Co. Murdock sues Obewon claiming the firm negligently made the lawnmower. Murdock further claims he has been disabled from doing his job and seeks damages for loss of earning capacity. Obewon sends a request for production of Murdocks income tax returns for the five years before the injury and two years after the injury. What is the result? Why?