Name Student ID Problem 3. Flooding has been major problem in Thailand for so long. The government consider three alternatives to prevent this problem as show in the table below. All alternatives are considered to last forever, and MARR is 15% per year Alternative 2. Build Drainage Tunnel 500 38,000 1. Build 3 Dams 3.000 60,000 1,200 4,000 (Every 10 Years) 15.000 5.000 800 500 (Every 4 years) Unit: Million Baht Land Surrender Fee Construction Cost Annual Maintenance Cost Overhual Cost Annual Benefit on Irrigation Aspect Annual Benefit on Trasportation Aspect Annual Saving from Flooding Annual Disbenefit to People in the area Annual Disbenefit to Environment Saving from Japanese Government Salvage Value 12.000 3. Build Floodway 12.000 100,000 2,000 7,000 (Every 15 years) 22.000 3.500 4,000 4,000 2,500 2.000 1,000 1.500 4.000 2.000 2,000 0 400 600 2.000 3.500 Show your solution to get full score. 3.1 (5 Points) Determine which one() should the government select, based on Conventional B/C Ratio. All alternatives are independent. Name ......................... Student ID ....................... 3.2 (5 Points) Determine which one(s) should the government select, based on Conventional B/C Ratio. All alternatives are Mutually Exclusive. Name Student ID Problem 3. Flooding has been major problem in Thailand for so long. The government consider three alternatives to prevent this problem as show in the table below. All alternatives are considered to last forever, and MARR is 15% per year Alternative 2. Build Drainage Tunnel 500 38,000 1. Build 3 Dams 3.000 60,000 1,200 4,000 (Every 10 Years) 15.000 5.000 800 500 (Every 4 years) Unit: Million Baht Land Surrender Fee Construction Cost Annual Maintenance Cost Overhual Cost Annual Benefit on Irrigation Aspect Annual Benefit on Trasportation Aspect Annual Saving from Flooding Annual Disbenefit to People in the area Annual Disbenefit to Environment Saving from Japanese Government Salvage Value 12.000 3. Build Floodway 12.000 100,000 2,000 7,000 (Every 15 years) 22.000 3.500 4,000 4,000 2,500 2.000 1,000 1.500 4.000 2.000 2,000 0 400 600 2.000 3.500 Show your solution to get full score. 3.1 (5 Points) Determine which one() should the government select, based on Conventional B/C Ratio. All alternatives are independent. Name ......................... Student ID ....................... 3.2 (5 Points) Determine which one(s) should the government select, based on Conventional B/C Ratio. All alternatives are Mutually Exclusive
