Old Mr Smith, feeling that he will no longer be able to look after himself.

2. Old Mr. Smith, feeling that he will no longer be able to look after himself for many more years, wrote to Jane, his unmarried daughter, suggesting that she come and live near him. He offered to buy her a flat to live in. Jane accepted his offer, gave up her job and council house and moved into the flat which her father had bought for her. Mr. Smith paid the whole purchase price and the flat was conveyed to his name. Whenever Jane suggested that she would like the flat to be conveyed to her name, he dismissed the idea as absurd, saying, "I am leaving everything to you in my will anyway". Mr. Smith paid all the outgoings on the flat and Jane paid nothing. Jane found a part- time job and visited her father daily helping him around the house. This arrangement continued happily for two years until Mr. Smith died, leaving all his property to charity. His executors now seek possession of the flat. Advise Jane. Would your advice be any different if Jane had provided one-fifth of the purchase price of the flat