On p. 85 question 2, the argument in the scenario was invalid. Discuss the logical fallacies that apply to the reasoning and why they matter in light of the scenario.

You are engaged in an intense discussion with your friend, Bill, who works in the IT department at your university. Bill complains that many stu- dents are using P2P (peer-to-peer) file-sharing applications on the university's network to down- load excessive amounts of unauthorized copy- righted material. He also claims that the most effective solution to this problem would be to dis- able student access to all (existing) P2P sites and to prevent students at your institution from setting their own P2P sites for any reason whatsoever (even to include noncopyrighted material). You convey to Bill your belief that this measure is too drastic. However, Bill argues that the only way to eliminate unauthorized file sharing among stu- dents at your institution is to disable access to all P2P software on the university's network. up