Answered step by step
Verified Expert Solution
Link Copied!

Question

1 Approved Answer

Prove the case involving E of the inductive step of the (strong) soundness theorem for natural deduction in classical propositional logic(you should use the format

Prove the case involving E of the inductive step of the (strong) soundness theorem for natural deduction in classical propositional logic(you should use the format like below).

image text in transcribedimage text in transcribed

(Strong) soundness INDUCTIVE STEP: suppose that, for any R and A, if RFA with a proof of size n, then REA (IH). We want to prove that if S + B with a proof of size n+1, then SEB. Case 6: the step n+1 is obtained via -I. This means that B = -C for some formula C which was assumed earlier and produced al at the step n of the proof. This means that SU {C} + I with a proof of size at most n. Then, by IH, SU {C} = I. But this means that no interpretation can give the truth value 1 to all formulas in S and to C (because such interpretation would need to give (1) = 1, which is impossible). Then, an interpretation that gives the truth value 1 to all formulas in S must give v(C) = 0, and hence v(-C) = 1. That is, SEB as wanted. (Strong) soundness INDUCTIVE STEP: suppose that, for any R and A, if RFA with a proof of size n, then REA (IH). We want to prove that if SEB with a proof of size n+1, then SEB. Case 7: the step n+1 is obtained via -E. This is your duty to prove (Assignment 2, Ex. 2) 16:45 2 12 owl.uwo.ca 31/42 LOVE THAT EX: PROVE THAT Pv (QAR) +(PvQ) 1 (PvR) [P]. [P) [qur 7 COURSE PuQ PR - Pie PUR Bucano) (Pug). (PUR) Poq)n (PUR) VE [1,2] (PQ)^(PUR) PvQiR) - PuQ) 1 (PvR) -AI I [o] WE SEE THAT WE CAN IMMEDIATELY DISCHARGE IT WITH AN ADDITIONAL APPH CATION OF I (Strong) soundness INDUCTIVE STEP: suppose that, for any R and A, if RFA with a proof of size n, then REA (IH). We want to prove that if S + B with a proof of size n+1, then SEB. Case 6: the step n+1 is obtained via -I. This means that B = -C for some formula C which was assumed earlier and produced al at the step n of the proof. This means that SU {C} + I with a proof of size at most n. Then, by IH, SU {C} = I. But this means that no interpretation can give the truth value 1 to all formulas in S and to C (because such interpretation would need to give (1) = 1, which is impossible). Then, an interpretation that gives the truth value 1 to all formulas in S must give v(C) = 0, and hence v(-C) = 1. That is, SEB as wanted. (Strong) soundness INDUCTIVE STEP: suppose that, for any R and A, if RFA with a proof of size n, then REA (IH). We want to prove that if SEB with a proof of size n+1, then SEB. Case 7: the step n+1 is obtained via -E. This is your duty to prove (Assignment 2, Ex. 2) 16:45 2 12 owl.uwo.ca 31/42 LOVE THAT EX: PROVE THAT Pv (QAR) +(PvQ) 1 (PvR) [P]. [P) [qur 7 COURSE PuQ PR - Pie PUR Bucano) (Pug). (PUR) Poq)n (PUR) VE [1,2] (PQ)^(PUR) PvQiR) - PuQ) 1 (PvR) -AI I [o] WE SEE THAT WE CAN IMMEDIATELY DISCHARGE IT WITH AN ADDITIONAL APPH CATION OF

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

Step: 1

blur-text-image

Get Instant Access to Expert-Tailored Solutions

See step-by-step solutions with expert insights and AI powered tools for academic success

Step: 2

blur-text-image_2

Step: 3

blur-text-image_3

Ace Your Homework with AI

Get the answers you need in no time with our AI-driven, step-by-step assistance

Get Started

Recommended Textbook for

Relational Database And SQL

Authors: Lucy Scott

3rd Edition

1087899699, 978-1087899695

More Books

Students also viewed these Databases questions

Question

Have a brief review of human motivation theories

Answered: 1 week ago

Question

Define and measure service productivity.

Answered: 1 week ago